The formation of crossovers is a fundamental genetic process. The XPF-family endonuclease Mus81-Mms4 (Eme1) contributes significantly to crossing over in eukaryotes. A key question is whether Mus81-Mms4 can process Holliday junctions that contain four uninterrupted strands. Holliday junction cleavage requires the coordination of two active sites, necessitating the assembly of two Mus81-Mms4 heterodimers. Contrary to this expectation, we show that Saccharomyces cerevisiae Mus81-Mms4 exists as a single heterodimer both in solution and when bound to DNA substrates in vitro. Consistently, immunoprecipitation experiments demonstrate that Mus81-Mms4 does not multimerize in vivo. Moreover, chromatin-bound Mus81-Mms4 does not detectably form higher-order multimers. We show that Cdc5 kinase activates Mus81-Mms4 nuclease activity on 3= flaps and Holliday junctions in vitro but that activation does not induce a preference for Holliday junctions and does not induce multimerization of the Mus81-Mms4 heterodimer. These data support a model in which Mus81-Mms4 cleaves nicked recombination intermediates such as displacement loops (D-loops), nicked Holliday junctions, or 3= flaps but not intact Holliday junctions with four uninterrupted strands. We infer that Mus81-dependent crossing over occurs in a noncanonical manner that does not involve the coordinated cleavage of classic Holliday junctions.
Robin Holliday first proposed a mechanism for crossover formation (29). Based on fungal tetrad data, he envisioned that nick-induced heteroduplex formation could result in a DNA intermediate composed of four intact strands after ligation of the strand interruptions. This intermediate was later termed the Holliday junction (HJ). Cleavage across the two alternative planes of this junction would result in crossover (CO) or noncrossover (NCO) products, depending on the orientation of cleavage. Biochemical analysis of the bacterial RuvC nuclease supports this model and provides a paradigm for a class of enzymes called Holliday junction resolvases. These nucleases form homodimeric complexes to deliver two coordinated and symmetric endonucleolytic cuts that generate DNA ends that can be directly ligated to form recombinant products (reviewed in reference 38). However, RuvC is not evolutionarily conserved in eukaryotes, and the specific mechanisms of crossover formation in eukaryotes are still undefined. Refinement and expansion of the original Holliday model have produced the current model of double-strand break repair, in which one subpathway is defined by the formation of a double Holliday junction (dHJ) (46). Physical analysis has demonstrated the existence of dHJs in meiotic and mitotic recombination (12, 48). However, these studies could not establish whether these junctions were truly dHJs, i.e., with each individual junction having four uninterrupted strands, or were nicked junctions in a dHJ population where each strand could be found to be full length (for more discussion, see reference 49). Hence, the importance of Holliday junctions...