Borrowers in Search of Feedback: Evidence from Consumer Credit Markets

Abstract

We study recent technological innovation in credit markets and document their role in providing information to households. We show that households value the ability to learn detailed information about their cost of credit. This function is most valued by less creditworthy households with less experience in credit markets. To measure the demand for information provision we exploit a quasi-natural experiment in an online consumer credit market. A large lending platform unexpectedly switched from pricing loans through an auction mechanism to centralized pricing determined by broad credit grade. This change resulted in an instant decrease in the amount of tailored feedback available to market participants. We find that less experienced households immediately and disproportionately exit the market and the response is concentrated among higher risk households. We rule out alternative explanations such as changes in access to credit, borrower risk profiles, and interest rate levels. Our findings point to a potentially important role for financial innovation: enabling less experienced households to more easily learn about their credit market options. * We thank

Credit Rationing in P2P Lending to SMEs: Do Lender-Borrower Relationships Matter?

“…These findings also complement those on optimal platform design. When moving to a system with posted prices, the informational efficiency associated with an auction system is reduced (Franks et al, 2020;Liskovich and Shaton, 2017). Instead, certain investors could benefit from having more information or better abilities to process information.…”

A Survey of Fintech Research and Policy Discussion

“…Participation of sophisticated investors could potentially improve the screening outcomes but also could create adverse selection among investors (Hildebrandt, Puri, and Rocholl (2017)). Vallee and Zeng (2019) and Liskovich and Shaton (2017) find that sophisticated investors tend to outperform less experienced ones, especially when platforms provide more sufficient information to investors through websites or application programming interfaces (API).…”

Marketplace Lending, Information Aggregation, and Liquidity

“…They nd a reduction in the quality of information produced by online nancial analysis and, as a result, a deterioration in information eciency. Finally, several studies show how the design of peer-to-peer marketplaces aects the matching between borrowing households and contract terms (Hertzberg, Liberman, and Paravisini, 2017; Cespedes, 2017; Liskovich and Shaton, 2017).…”