aryl radicals · CÀH activation · homolytic radical substitutions · organocatalysis · radical anionsThe research groups of Shi, [1] Shirakawa/Hayashi, [2] and Kwong/Lei [3] have recently reported independently on the construction of biaryl compounds from unactivated aromatic rings by direct CÀH activation with the aid of organocatalysts.[4] Published in J. Am. Chem. Soc. and Nature Chem., the results were described as "conceptual breakthroughs" [1,3] because no metal catalyst was needed.Here we suggest that these exciting results are not best viewed in terms of C À H activation or organocatalysis, but instead in terms of homolytic radical aromatic substitution (HAS). [5][6][7][8][9] Although the results may not be conceptual breakthroughs from that viewpoint, they could well herald new opportunities for making organic molecules through organic radical and radical anion reactions.Kwong, Lei, and co-workers discovered that heating aryl iodides in benzene at 80 8C with one equivalent of potassium tert-butoxide and 20 mol % N,N'-dimethylethylenediamine (DMEDA, the organocatalyst) gave biaryls in good yields (60-85 %, Scheme 1).[3] The research groups of Shirakawa/ Hayashi [2] and Shi [1] described similar bimolecular reactions in comparable yields, although their organocatalyst was 1,10-phenanthroline (or a substituted analogue) and used at a level of 20 and 40 mol %, respectively. In addition, Shi and co-workers reported an example of a cyclization: heating 2-iodophenyl benzyl ether (1) in mesitylene with potassium tert-butoxide (3 equiv) and 1,10-phenanthroline provided benzochromene 2 in 75 % yield.In 2008, Itami and co-workers reported that potassium tert-butoxide (1.5 equiv) alone effected the addition of aryl iodides and bromides to pyridizine and other electron-poor aromatic rings. [10,11] These results are reminiscent of the Minisci reaction (addition of alkyl and other radicals to electron-poor heterocycles), [12] except that Minisci reactions are usually conducted under acidic conditions rather than basic conditions. The research groups [1,3,4] discovered these transformations through control experiments while trying to develop metal-catalyzed C À H activation reactions. They observed that with certain "ligands" and KOtBu, the metal was not needed at all to effect the conversion of the aryl halide into the biaryl. Extensive control experiments and trace analyses (Shi and co-workers, [1] Itami and co-workers [10] ) were performed to ensure that the conditions were indeed metal-free. Coming from this direction, the processes look like organocatalylic CÀH activation reactions.In all these reports there are suggestions that aryl radicals are intermediates. The scope and conditions of the reactions (large excess of acceptor needed) and the H/D isotope effects are consistent with aryl radicals being involved. The addition of 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-piperidinoxyl (TEMPO) and other inhibitors blocked the reactions, [1,3,10] and the successful cyclization of 1 to 2 is consistent with an aryl radical intermediate. Final...