Acceptorless alcohol dehydrogenation is a powerful reaction in sustainable synthesis. When combined in a tandem reaction with dehydrogenative coupling or hydrogen borrowing, acceptorless dehydrogenation can be used for the environmentally benign construction of C−C, C−N, and C−O bonds. While many of these reactions rely on using precious metals, in the past decade the use of earth-abundant metals has become more prevalent. If a green and renewable feedstock could be introduced as well, the sustainability of the acceptorless dehydrogenation could further be increased. Methanol would be such a substrate and could serve as a renewable C1 source when used for the methylation of a wide variety of substrates. Herein, we report the efficient manganesecatalyzed α-methylation of ketones and indoles. The manganese catalyst is based on a PC NHC P pincer platform containing a rare central carbene donor. The reaction supports a diverse set of functional groups, occurs at moderate temperatures (110 °C), and provides the corresponding methylated ketones and indoles in excellent yields. In contrast to previously reported mechanisms, the herein reported mechanism does not depend on metal−ligand cooperativity but rather proceeds via (i) a metal-based mechanism featuring a manganese hydride or (ii) via a ligand-centered mechanism where a manganese-carbonyl acts as catalytic center, depending on the used additive.