Careers of skilled migrants: understanding the experiences of Malagasy physicians in France

Abstract

Purpose -France is a country that widely relies on a skilled labour force. Nevertheless, very little is written in the management literature on the career experiences of skilled migrants, in particular from developing countries, in France. This paper argues that in order to understand the management of skilled migrants in France, there is a need to better understand their career experiences. Therefore, the objective of this paper is to fill this knowledge gap by offering an enhanced understanding of the career experiences of Malagasy migrant physicians in France. Design/methodology/approach -Based on the life story of 17 Malagasy migrant physicians and an interview with a Malagasy director of a private clinic who recruited Malagasy physicians to work in France, the paper sheds light on their career choices and challenges that they face in the French job market. Findings -The results clearly highlight two career profiles: firstly, those who succeeded in working as physicians either directly upon their graduation, or throughout an "interstitial" career in nursing, a way to eventually reach their profession of physician. Second, findings show that there were participants who definitively switched to a nursing profession. For this second group, migration emerges as a challenging experience leading to talent waste and therefore to downward career mobility. Originality/value -While literature on international careers frequently describe international mobility as being beneficial for skilled migrants, the findings yield limited support for this assumption. Instead, human capital was insufficient in explaining the career outcome of migrant physicians in France. Beyond the assumption that human capital is sufficient for undertaking a successful international experience, the paper contribute's to the literature on international careers by focusing on an under-researched group (i.e. Malagasy physicians in France) and demonstrating the complex nature of their career experiences.

High-skilled female immigrants: career strategies and experiences

“…Accordingly, adults are often motivated to learn due to a problem, issue, or challenge they face personally or professionally. One salient problem that motivates high-skilled female immigrants -based on findings from this study and previous literature -is the status collapse they experience in their careers upon migrating to a new land (Chiswick et al, 2005;Fossland, 2012;Liversage, 2009;Ramboarison-Lalao et al, 2012). Our results show that those immigrants who perceive a status collapse to be problematic to their self-concept proactively set the learning cycle in motion.…”

Migrant CEOs: Barriers and Strategies on the Way to the Top

“…Also migrants may find it difficult to have their qualifications recognized and skills acknowledged by organizations in their host countries (Painter, ) and therefore end up accepting positions non‐commensurable with their professional and academic qualifications (Almeida et al, ). In addition, professional associations and licensing bodies are known to set the boundaries of entry and access to elite professions such as medical doctors, lawyers, accountants, among others (Ramboarison‐Lalao, Al Ariss and Barth, ). These trends hinder the internationalization of professional services and limit the employment opportunities for skilled migrants.…”

Fitting the mould: the role of employer perceptions in immigrant recruitment decision-making

“…However, despite the rigorous assessment of migrants' qualifications and experiences, research suggests that skilled migrants from nonEnglish speaking backgrounds (NESBs) are less successful in finding employment that matches their skills than their English-speaking counterparts . Such underutilization is common in Western countries, including Britain (Qureshi et al, 2013), Canada (Somerville and Walsworth, 2009) and France (Ramboarison-Lalao et al, 2012).…”