A new transition-state model was developed in order to justify the anti intramolecular E2 elimination
with cis (Z)-preference over pure alumina and intermolecular E2 elimination with trans (E)-preference over doped alumina. The reactions of model compounds 1,2,3-triphenyl-2-propanol (1),
1,2-diphenyl-2-propanol (2), and 3,3,3-trideuterio-1,2-diphenyl-2-propanol (3) with aluminum oxides
with a pH range of 4.5−9.5 and thorium oxide in the temperature range of 200−350 °C in 2-hexanol
have been investigated. Over acidic alumina (pH = 4.5 ± 0.5), the ratio of E-isomer to Z-isomer
(E/Z ≅ 2) for 2 was found to remain unchanged in this temperature range. At 300 °C, however,
Saytzeff elimination favored Hofmann. Over pure alumina the E/Z ratio was equal to 0.650 (2-alkene/1-alkene = 0.750). At equilibrium, the E/Z ratio for 2 was equal to 4.5 with the formation
of trace amounts of Hofmann adducts. The ratio of Saytzeff to Hofmann elimination was found to
be pH independent. Any decrease in pH caused a slight increase in the E/Z ratio. The average
primary kinetic isotope effect (k
H/k
D) for elimination at 230 °C was equal to 3.775 ± 0.227. The
ratio of E/Z over thorium oxide at 300 and 350 °C was similar to that of aluminum oxide at 300
°C, but the Saytzeff elimination was surprisingly favored over Hofmann! The energy of activation
(E
a), entropy of activation (ΔS
⧧), selectivity, isotope effect (k
H/k
D), and semiempirical calculation
(AM1) all agreed with concerted E2 elimination.