Causes and consequences of error in digital elevation models

Abstract

All digital data contain error and many are uncertain. Digital models of elevation surfaces consist of files containing large numbers of measurements representing the height of the surface of the earth, and therefore a proportion of those measurements are very likely to be subject to some level of error and uncertainty. The collection and handling of such data and their associated uncertainties has been a subject of considerable research, which has focused largely upon the description of the effects of interpolation and resolution uncertainties, as well as modelling the occurrence of errors. However, digital models of elevation derived from new technologies employing active methods of laser and radar ranging are becoming more widespread, and past research will need to be re-evaluated in the near future to accommodate such new data products. In this paper we review the source and nature of errors in digital models of elevation, and in the derivatives of such models. We examine the correction of errors and assessment of fitness for use, and finally we identify some priorities for future research.

Automated Mapping of Permanent Preservation Areas on Hilltops

“…Although digital representations of relief are approximations of reality, and are subject to errors and uncertainties (FISHER and TATE, 2006), the development of generic models of automated mapping represent major advance on the issue.…”

Investigating the Role of DEM Resolution and Accuracy on Flood Inundation Mapping

“…It is used to report a single global value of error in elevations for the entire DEM (Fisher & Tate, 2006). For this study, RMSE is used to evaluate the difference in accuracy between the original LiDAR data and its resampled DEMs.…”

“…It is measured by the amount of linear error in elevation (ESRI, 2014b). The accuracy of a DEM directly influences the hydraulic modeling results (Darnell et al, 2008;Fisher & Tate, 2006). Thus, DEM resolution and accuracy have a significant impact on water surface elevations and flood extents.…”

Propagation of vertical and horizontal source data errors into a TIN with linear interpolation

“…Gessesse et al, 2010;Fonstad et al, 2013). Point measurements acquired directly from land surveying were less frequently used to create DEMs in the past (Fisher and Tate, 2006). However, point measurement sources have become increasingly popular in recent years since differential global positioning system (DGPS) and laser scanning systems have come to be used more widely (e.g.…”

“…Historically, the source data used for the generation of DEMs have most frequently come from contour lines, paper maps and imagery such as stereo aerial photographs (Fisher and Tate, 2006;Zhu et al, 2005). Imagery from various platforms still represents a popular source of data with which to construct DEMs (e.g.…”