Causes and consequences of intraspecific variation in animal responses to anthropogenic noise

Abstract

Anthropogenic noise is a recognized global pollutant, affecting a wide range of nonhuman animals. However, most research considers only whether noise pollution has an impact, ignoring that individuals within a species or population exhibit substantial variation in responses to stress. Here, we first outline how intrinsic characteristics (e.g., body size, condition, sex, and personality) and extrinsic factors (e.g., environmental context, repeated exposure, prior experience, and multiple stressors) can affect responses to environmental stressors. We then present the results of a systematic search of the anthropogenic-noise literature, identifying articles that investigated intraspecific variation in the responses of nonhuman animals to noise. This reveals that fewer than 10% of articles (51 of 589) examining impacts of noise test experimentally for intraspecific variation in responses; of those that do, more than 75% report significant effects. We assess these existing studies to determine the current scope of research and findings to-date, and to provide suggestions for good practice in the design, implementation, and reporting of robust experiments in this field. We close by explaining how understanding intraspecific variation in responses to anthropogenic noise is crucial for improving how we manage captive animals, monitor wild populations, model species responses, and mitigate effects of noise pollution on wildlife. Our aim is to stimulate greater knowledge and more effective management of the harmful consequences of this global pollutant.

Environmental unpredictability shapes glucocorticoid regulation across populations of tree swallows

“…Our results are also in accordance with the hypothesis that negative feedback and the dynamic regulation of glucocorticoids are important for coping with challenging conditions 21,37,53 . In the current context of global changes, intraspecific differences in the response to stressors may be particularly important for survival or for the ability to adapt to new conditions 4,54 . Our results suggest that this phenotype (elevated stress response and strong negative feedback) could have been selected for in females breeding in unpredictable environments and might therefore be expected to become increasingly common over time, assuming genetic variation exists.…”

Extreme Effects of Extreme Disturbances: A Simulation Approach to Assess Population Specific Responses

“…Extreme events were seen to have the greatest influence on the population trends and reproduction of dolphins during simulations. The understanding that different species may respond differently to the same disturbance is widely accepted, but differences in the context in which a disturbance occurs may also lead to a large variation of responses within a species (Harding et al, 2019;Radford et al, 2019). Modeled scenarios rely heavily on the choice of input parameters, which were carefully chosen either from the study population itself or from similar proxy populations, but these are only approximations of what may occur in real populations.…”

Mapping Shade Availability and Use in Zoo Environments: A Tool for Evaluating Thermal Comfort

“…Modern zoos are interested in creating environments that can enhance the welfare of individual animals. Previous studies have documented a range of environmental variables that can impact welfare, including noise, lighting, and human presence (e.g., [1][2][3][4][5][6][7]). The thermal environment is likely to play a key role in the behavior and welfare of individuals as well, particularly for megafauna that are commonly housed outdoors, given the metabolic consequences of a large body size and allometric scaling of surface area to volume [8,9].…”