CDK5/p35 is a cyclin-dependent kinase essential for normal neuron function. Proteolysis of the p35 subunit in vivo results in CDK5/p25 that causes neurotoxicity associated with a number of neurodegenerative diseases. Whereas the mechanism by which conversion of p35 to p25 leads to toxicity is unknown, there is common belief that CDK5/p25 is catalytically hyperactive compared to CDK5/p35. Here, we have compared the steady-state kinetic parameters of CDK5/p35 and CDK5/p25 towards both histone H1, the best known substrate for both enzymes, and the microtubule-associated protein, tau, a physiological substrate whose in vivo phosphorylation is relevant to Alzheimer's disease. We show that the kinetics of both enzymes are the same towards either substrate in vitro. Furthermore, both enzymes display virtually identical kinetics towards individual phosphorylation sites in tau monitored by NMR. We conclude that conversion of p35 to p25 does not alter the catalytic efficiency of the CDK5 catalytic subunit by using histone H1 or tau as substrates, and that neurotoxicity associated with CDK5/p25 is unlikely attributable to CDK5 hyperactivation, as measured in vitro.Alzheimer's disease | neurotoxicity | NMR | protein kinase | proteolysis C DK5/p25 was first identified as a tau kinase (1, 2) that displayed a CDK1 (formerly p34 cdc2 ) -like substrate specificity in brain (3, 4). Of particular interest, phosphorylation of normal tau by CDK5/p25 could partially recapitulate several characteristics inherent to PHF-tau associated with Alzheimer's disease (1, 2). The CDK5 catalytic subunit was homologous to other CDKs and displayed ubiquitous expression (5), but p25 was originally discovered as a unique protein expressed predominantly in neurons, and generated by proteolytic cleavage of a larger protein precursor, p35 (6-9). Whereas CDK5/p35 is associated with normal neuron development and function (10), endogenous cleavage of p35 to p25 is associated with neuronal cell death, neuropathology, and is implicated in the progression of Alzheimer's disease (11-18), Parkinson's disease (19), and ALS (20). CDK5/p25, but not CDK5/p35, is toxic when overexpressed in transformed cell lines or when generated by cleavage of endogenous p35 in neurons (11,21,22). The cellular mechanism by which cleavage causes toxicity is not known, but in theory could relate to one or more known key differences between these two enzyme forms, including differences in subcellular distribution (11, 23), stability of the protein (11, 24), and/or cellular substrate specificity (11,25).There is common belief that the catalytic activity of CDK5/p25 is significantly elevated in comparison to CDK5/p35, and therefore that p25 causes "hyperactivity" of CDK5 compared to p35, contributing to its toxicity (10). To rigorously demonstrate its hyperactivity, however, it is necessary to show that the catalytic parameters associated with steady-state phosphorylation of substrates are different between the two enzymes. Hashiguchi et al. (26) previously conducted such experiments,...