e21I t seems that every decade seminal observations related to the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis are revisited especially when new technology, animal models, or reagents are developed. This is the case with this study by Robbins et al 1 from the Massachusetts General Hospital. These investigators have used a variety of powerful techniques to address the question of what roles macrophage proliferation and monocyte recruitment play in accounting for the numbers of macrophages within the intima of atherosclerotic plaques in mice at different stages of lesion development. This study makes an important new contribution because it provides quantitative evidence that monocyte recruitment followed by differentiation into macrophages predominates at early stages of lesion development in mice, whereas macrophage proliferation is predominant at later stages.The authors started by continuously infusing the thymidine analogue, bromodeoxyuridine (BrDU) into 4-month-old apolipoprotein E-deficient (ApoE −/− ) mice on a high cholesterol diet. After enzyme digestion of the aorta, they measured the BrDU incorporation into macrophages (Lin − CD11b + CD11c −/low F4/80 high cells) by flow cytometry and found that 92% of the macrophages were labeled. They corroborated these finding by also analyzing 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole staining for S/G 2 /M phase cells, H3 histone phosphorylation, and positive immunostaining for another proliferation marker Ki67 in tissue sections. Depletion of circulating monocytes had no effect on BrDU incorporation, suggesting that monocyte recruitment was not playing a role in replenishing the pool of proliferating macrophages in the established lesions. They analyzed this further using the classical technique of parabiosis. They joined the circulations of diet-fed 4-month-old CD45.1 + ApoE −/− mice with established lesions with CD45.2 + ApoE −/− mice for 5 weeks. They found low levels (5%) of macrophage chimerism in the aortic lesions. Separation of the parabionts also had no effect on the number of macrophage chimeras in the established plaques. In contrast, when they joined 8-week-old mice that had not been fed the high cholesterol diet before parabiosis and measured chimerism 4 weeks later, the percent chimerism was similar for circulating monocytes and the macrophages within the early lesions indicating that monocyte recruitment was the likely source of the macrophages in the early lesions. H-thymidine autoradiography to provide more definitive data that cellular proliferation was an active process within the rabbit lesions. Shortly thereafter, thymidine incorporation was further documented in lesions from rabbits, 5,6 swine, 7 Rhesus monkeys, 8 and humans.
9In the 1980s, several of us at the University of Washington applied newly developed cell type-specific monoclonal antibodies (RAM-11 and HAM-56) to definitively demonstrate that the labeled cells were both macrophages and smooth muscle cells. [10][11][12] In studies of Watanabe Heritable Hyperlipemic (WHHL) and comparably hypercholesterolemic ...