DNA double-strand breaks induced by ionizing radiation are often accompanied by
ancillary oxidative base damage that may prevent or delay their repair. In order to better
define the features that make some DSBs repair-resistant, XLF-dependent nonhomologous end
joining of blunt-ended DSB substrates having the oxidatively modified nonplanar base
thymine glycol at the first (Tg1), second (Tg2), third (Tg3) or fifth (Tg5) positions from
one 3′ terminus, was examined in human whole-cell extracts. Tg at the third
position had little effect on end-joining even when present on both ends of the break.
However, Tg as the terminal or penultimate base was a major barrier to end joining
(>10-fold reduction in ligated products) and an absolute barrier when present at both
ends. Dideoxy trapping of base excision repair intermediates indicated that Tg was excised
from Tg1, Tg2 and Tg3 largely if not exclusively after DSB ligation. However, Tg was
rapidly excised from the Tg5 substrate, resulting in a reduced level of DSB ligation, as
well as slow concomitant resection of the opposite strand. Ligase reactions containing
only purified Ku, XRCC4, ligase IV and XLF showed that ligation of Tg3 and Tg5 was
efficient and only partially XLF-dependent, whereas ligation of Tg1 and Tg2 was
inefficient and only detectable in the presence of XLF. Overall, the results suggest that
promoting ligation of DSBs with proximal base damage may be an important function of XLF,
but that Tg can still be a major impediment to repair, being relatively resistant to both
trimming and ligation. Moreover, it appears that base excision repair of Tg can sometimes
interfere with repair of DSBs that would otherwise be readily rejoined.