In this prospective study, we evaluated the steroid levels in 111 follicular fluids (FF) collected from 13 women stimulated with FSH monotherapy and 205 FF collected from 28 women stimulated with FSH + LH because of a previous history of hypo-responsiveness to FSH. Steroid levels were measured by HPLC/MS-MS and related to ovarian stimulation protocol, oocyte maturity, fertilization and quality of blastocysts, after individually tracking the fate of all retrieved oocytes. 17-Hydroxy-Progesterone, Androstenedione, Estradiol and Estrone were significantly higher in the FSH + LH protocol. Progesterone, 17-Hydroxy-Progesterone and Estradiol were more expressed in FF yielding a mature oocyte (p < 0.01) in the FSH + LH protocol. FF Progesterone concentration was correlated with the rate of normal fertilization in the FSH protocol. None of the FF steroids measured were associated with blastocyst quality and achievement of pregnancy. Our results indicate that LH supplementation in hypo-responsive women modifies ovarian steroid production, mimicking physiological production better and likely contributing to an improved ovarian response. Employing a correct methodological procedure to evaluate the relationship between FF steroid hormones and assisted reproduction outcomes, our study reveals that some steroids in single follicles may be helpful in predicting oocyte maturity and fertilization. Infertility is a global problem estimated to affect about 80 million couples in the world. Infertile couples may rely on assisted reproduction techniques (ARTs) which include IVF (in vitro fertilization) and ICSI (intracytoplasmic sperm injection) to achieve a pregnancy. These treatments not only aim at solving fertility problems but also offer a great opportunity to study human reproductive physiology more in depth, presenting the chance to benefit from biological fluids otherwise impossible to obtain. For instance, human follicular fluid (FF) samples provide a crucial microenvironment involved in oocyte development. Their composition depends largely on secretions of granulosa and thecal cells and is influenced by hormonal, paracrine and autocrine signals 1. In ARTs, all mature retrieved oocytes are usually fertilized but only a part of them develops into an embryo which results in a successful implantation. Clarifying which factors in FF regulate the development and acquisition of oocyte competence is a major goal of current research.