Subarachnoid basal cistern opening (cisternotomy) is used during many microsurgical operations to relax the brain by removing or diverting cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Recently, cisternotomy has been used in patients with traumatic brain injury to improve outcomes due to its ability to decrease intracranial pressure (ICP) and brain edema by diverting CSF. Theoretically, another condition that can benefit from cisternotomy is idiopathic intracranial hypertension (IIH) as it presents with manifestations of increased ICP, such as headache, vomiting, and papilledema. Here, we discuss the case of a 39-year-old woman with IIH who presented with headache, nausea, and papilledema in the setting of maximally tolerated medical management after five months of shunt removal due to infection. The patient did not want to proceed with the replacement of her shunt and therefore underwent a right eyebrow craniotomy for cisternotomy, lamina terminals fenestration, and Liliequist's membrane opening. Postoperatively, her symptoms improved completely. She was off acetazolamide altogether at the three-month follow-up and no longer had pseudotumor cerebri headaches. This case report demonstrates the use of cisternotomy to relieve the manifestations of increased ICP and its potential as a surgical option for patients with IIH.