“…In addition, some of the design equations provided in Table I of [2] are incorrect and ambiguous. For example, the provided equation of the load reactance (XL) implies that it is capacitive, but not inductive as indicated in Table I and in the circuit schematic of Fig.4 in [2]. Further, the provided equation for the injection resistance (Rinj) implies the presence of a physical resistor between the main and the auxiliary circuit, but on the other hand, the model of the Class-EM PA does not account for such physical resistor.…”