Clinicians' abilities to estimate cardiac index in ventilated children and infants

Abstract

Objectives-To evaluate the ability of clinicians involved in the provision of paediatric intensive care to estimate cardiac index in ventilated children, based on physical examination and clinical and bedside laboratory data. Methods-Clinicians were exposed to all available haemodynamic and laboratory data for each patient, allowed to make a physical examination, and asked to first categorise cardiac index as high, high to normal, low to normal, or low, and then to quantify this further with a numerical estimate. Cardiac index was measured simultaneously by femoral artery thermodilution (coeYcient of variation 5.37%). One hundred and twelve estimates were made by 27 clinicians on 36 patients (median age 34.5 months). Results-Measured cardiac index ranged from 1.39 to 6.84 l/min/m 2 . Overall, there was poor correlation categorically ( statistic 0.09, weighted 0.169) and numerically (r = 0.24, 95% confidence interval 0.06 to 0.41 ), although some variation was seen among the various levels of seniority. Conclusion-Assuming that objective measurement, and hence manipulation, of haemodynamic variables may improve outcome, these findings support the need for a safe, accurate, and repeatable technique for measurement of cardiac index in children who are critically ill.

Cardiac Output Measurement Using a Modified Carbon Dioxide Fick Method: A Validation Study in Ventilated Lambs

“…In critically ill neonates, cardiac output is usually estimated from the interpretation of several clinical variables, such as blood pressure, urine output, blood gas analysis, and capillary refill. Tibby and colleagues (4) showed that clinicians using these indirect parameters of cardiac performance were unable to predict the actual cardiac output in ventilated children and infants. The same was shown in ventilated adults (5).…”

Fluid resuscitation of shock in children: what, whence and whither?

“…Furthermore, clinical assessment of cardiac output in children is notoriously unreliable [17]. Even invasive monitoring may be unhelpful.…”

Shock séptico en pediatría II: Enfoque actual en el diagnóstico y tratamiento

“…No obstante, es conocido que la habilidad del clínico para juzgar los parámetros hemodinámicos es pobre 31 .…”