Clopidogrel anti-platelet effect: An evaluation by optical aggregometry, impedance aggregometry, and the Platelet Function Analyzer (PFA-100™)

Abstract

Platelet aggregation inhibition by clopidogrel may be suboptimal in 4-30% of patients. Traditionally, optical aggregometry is used to assess clopidogrel's anti-platelet effects by inhibition of ADP-induced aggregation in platelet rich plasma. Red blood cells are an important source of ADP and, thus, are known to modulate platelet function. Because the whole blood aggregation by impedance method assesses platelet function in a physiological milieu, we compared clopidogrel response by this method with the optical method in platelet rich plasma (PRP) and the Platelet Function Analyzer (PFA-100). Platelet function studies were performed in 17 healthy subjects at baseline and after 10 days of clopidogrel intake (75 mg/day). Optical and impedance aggregometry were performed after addition of ADP (10 and 20 microM) and collagen (1 and 2 microg/mL). For PFA-100 analysis, whole blood closure time was measured in collagen-coated cartridges with ADP and epinephrine. All subjects except one showed a decrease in ADP-induced aggregation using both aggregation methods. However, ADP-induced platelet aggregation was significantly inhibited when assessed in whole blood as compared to the optical method (71+/- 34% vs. 34.2+/- 23%, p = 0.0002); this suggests that whole blood aggregometry is more sensitive in the detection of clopidogrel effect in the presence of red cells, which are known to modulate platelet function. The PFA-100 ADP closure time was slightly prolonged above the reference interval in only 5/17 (29%) subjects, suggesting that this instrument is not able to detect clopidogrel effect. We conclude that whole blood aggregation appears to be more sensitive in detecting clopidogrel effect compared with the platelet rich plasma method; the PFA-100 was unable to detect clopidogrel effect in the majority of the subjects.

Clinical importance of aspirin and clopidogrel resistance

“…Their result was in concordance with other studies [24,25] . The broad use of statins, angiotensin receptor blockers and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors may be, in part, responsible for the lack of agreement [26] .…”

Not all light transmission aggregation assays are created equal: qualitative differences between light transmission and 96-well plate aggregometry

“…In particular, AR-C66096 inhibited aggregations to collagen at all concentrations tested in 96-well aggregometry, but only at the lowest collagen concentration in LTA. Similarly, it has been previously shown that clopidogrel has greater effects upon collagen-induced aggregation measured in 96-well aggregometry than in LTA (8,9). We can speculate that differences in the volume of PRP and the presence or not of a stir bar play a critical role in determining fluid dynamics within the sample and the formation of aggregates dependent upon secondary mediators.…”

Evaluation of bleeding risk and measurement methods in dental patients

“…Posteriorly, the need to evaluate platelet function led to the development of technologies such as the PFA-100, a precise, convenient and reliable method that assesses platelet function globally and automatically in citrated whole blood (8,9). However, this system does not detect the effect of certain antiplatelet drugs upon platelet function (10)(11)(12). A recent introduction on the market has been the mentioned Multiplate System® analyzer, which uses different tests to generate reliable information on platelet function and on the effects of antiplatelet treatment.…”