<div>Electrocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2R) to fuels and chemicals is a pressing scientific</div><div>and engineering challenge that is, in part, hampered by a lack of understanding of the surface reaction</div><div>mechanism, even for relatively simple systems. While many efforts have been dedicated to promoting CO2R</div><div>on catalytic surfaces by tuning composition, morphology, and defects, the role of the reaction environment</div><div>around the active site, and how this can be leveraged to modulate CO2R, is less clear. To this end, we</div><div>focused on a model CO2R catalyst, Ag nanoparticles, and carried out a combined electrocatalytic and</div><div>operando Raman spectroscopic investigation of CO2R on their surfaces. Bare Ag and chemically modified</div><div>Ag nanoparticles were investigated to understand how the surface reaction environment dictates</div><div>intermediate binding and catalytic efficiency en route to CO generation. The results revealed that the</div><div>primary product on Ag is CO, which is formed through a doubly-bound CObridge configuration. In contrast,</div><div>electrografted imidazole and polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP)-coated Ag feature CO in a singly-bound COatop</div><div>configuration on their surfaces, whereas porous zeolitic-imidazolate framework-coated Ag was observed</div><div>to bind both CObridge and COatop. Further, another function of the Ag surface modifications is to dictate the</div><div>type of Ag surface sites which form Ag-C bonds with CO2R intermediates. Through analysis of the of</div><div>electrochemical and spectroscopic data, we deduce which key aspects of CO2R on Ag surface render a</div><div>CO2R system efficient and show how surface chemistry dictates diverging CO2R surface reaction</div><div>mechanisms. The insights gained here are important as they provide the community with a greater</div><div>understanding of heterogeneous CO2R and can be further translated to a number of catalytic systems. </div>