To cite this article: Fattorini A, Crippa L, DÕAngelo A. Artificially depleted plasmas are not necessarily commutable with native patient plasmas for International Sensitivity Index calibration and International Normalized Ratio derivation: rebuttal. J Thromb Haemost 2012; 10: 1715-6. We read with interest the letter by van den Besselar [1] about ISI calibrant plasmas and the ensuing exchange of correspondence with Poller et al. [2,3]. We agree with the ECAA colleagues that with the FDA-approved ECAA set of artificially depleted plasmas and the PT/INR line, inter-laboratory INR deviations are significantly reduced with all types of reagents, but we also suspect that, unless fresh native plasmas from patients on warfarin are used for calibration, this may not translate in better laboratory monitoring of patients on warfarin. van den Besselar [1] and Tripodi et al. [4] have reported discrepancies in INR between fresh and lyophilized samples with two rabbit thromboplastins and different coag-ulometers, but, given the advanced explanation of a different clotting factor composition of artificially depleted and native plasmas [3], we are afraid that such a discrepancy may also occur with reagents other than rabbit thromboplastins. With a STAR coagulometer and assuming Neoplastin Plus (Stago, Asniere sur Seine, France) as reference thromboplastin (certified coagulometer-specific ISI = 1.31) we have calculated on fresh plasma samples from stable patients on warfarin a coagulometer-specific ISI value of 0.77 (with Tomenson correction = 1.09) for Innovin (Siemens GmbH, Marburg, Germany) [5], which was confirmed in an independent series of 100 patients on warfarin [6]. In a recent multicentre study, Poller et al. [7] have validated the PT/INR line for coagulometer-specific ISI derivation. Six participants in that study used Innovin and STAR as the local reagent/instrument combination. The average stated values of these laboratories for ISI and MNPT before local calibration with either the ECAA set or the PT/INR line were 0.94 and 9.3 s, respectively. Given that no STAR specific ISI value for Innovin is provided by the manufacturer, we suspect that the stated ISI values were derived by local ISI calibration with the PT-Multi Calibrator set (Siemens), because using this set for the above-mentioned series of 100 patients on warfarin we have found a very similar STAR specific ISI value for Innovin of 0.96 (95% confidence interval, 0.95-0.97) with a derived MNPT of 10.2 s. According to the manufacturer, this set of six calibrator plasmas is obtained by pooling stabilized human plasma samples, some also containing a portion of animal plasma or of pretreated human plasma, followed by lyophilization. In the Poller et al. [7] study, coagulometer-specific ISI values and MNPT after local calibration with the ECAA calibrator set and the PT/INR line were 0.99 and 9.8 s and 1.06 and 10.6 s, respectively. The ECAA colleagues state that coagulo-meter-specific ISI values Ôcan be derived for the range of locally used thromboplastins and aut...