ObjectivesCisplatin‐related hearing loss (HL) is claimed to progress after treatment. This controlled longitudinal study with extended follow‐up investigates HL in testicular cancer survivors (TCSs) after cisplatin‐based chemotherapy (CBCT).Study DesignControlled longitudinal study.MethodsEighty‐two TCSs treated with CBCT between 1980 and 1994 in Norway participated in two surveys (S1/S3), including pure‐tone audiograms (0.125–8 kHz) and self‐reported HL, 12 and 31 years after treatment, respectively. Hearing thresholds were age‐adjusted based on age‐matched hearing thresholds from the general population (controls). Hearing loss was defined as thresholds >20 dB at any frequency.ResultsBetween the two surveys, the prevalence of high‐frequency HL (4, 6, and 8 kHz) increased from 73% to 94% but approached those of the aging general population after age adjustment. In TCSs aged >40 years at first survey, HL at the subsequent survey equaled that of controls. Self‐reported HL increased from seven (9%) at S1 to 20 (26%) at S3. At S1, age‐adjusted HL was identified in all (seven) TCSs reporting decreased hearing whereas at S3, hearing thresholds did not differ from controls in seven out of 20 patients reporting HL.ConclusionCBCT‐related ototoxicity causes high‐frequency HL, but in contrast to reports from follow‐up studies from the first post‐treatment decade, no major progression was found beyond the first post‐treatment decade for frequencies 0.125–8 kHz. Importantly, with extended follow‐up, hearing thresholds of patients approach those of the general population, possibly due to a less‐than‐additive effect with age‐related hearing loss (ARHL) in CBCT‐treated patients. Age‐and sex‐matching is strongly advised in long‐term follow‐up of CBCT‐related ototoxicity. Specificity for detecting ototoxicity with self‐reported questionnaires decreases with extended follow‐up.Level of Evidence3 Laryngoscope, 130:E515–E523, 2020