Loners, individuals out-of-sync with a coordinated majority, occur frequently in nature. 20 Are loners incidental byproducts of large-scale synchronization attempts or are they part of a 21 mosaic of life-history strategies? Here, we provide the first empirical evidence of naturally 22 occurring heritable variation in loner behavior, using the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum. 23 Moreover, we show that Dictyostelium loners-cells that do not join the multicellular life-stage-24 result from a dynamic population-partitioning process. Underlying this partitioning, we find 25 evidence that each cell makes a stochastic, signal-based decision resulting in an imperfectly 26 synchronized multicellular development affected by both abiotic (environmental porosity) and 27 biotic (strain-specific signaling) factors. Finally, we predict that when strains differing in their 28 partitioning behavior co-occur, cross-signaling impacts slime-mold diversity across spatio-29 temporal scales. Loners are therefore critical to understanding collective and social behaviors, 30 multicellular development, and ecological dynamics in D. discoideum. More broadly, across taxa, 31 imperfect synchronization might be adaptive by enabling diversification of life-history strategies. 32 33 Collective behaviors, in which a large number of individuals exhibit some degree of behavioral 34 synchronization, are frequent across the tree of life and across spatio-temporal scales: from 35 microbial aggregates to the great wildebeest migration, from locust swarming to synchronized 36 bamboo flowering, from fish schooling to mechanical adaptation in honeybee clusters (Couzin &