College chemistry students' mental models of acids and acid strength

Abstract

The central goal of this study was to characterize the mental models of acids and acid strength expressed by advanced college chemistry students when engaged in prediction, explanation, and justification tasks that asked them to rank chemical compounds based on their relative acid strength. For that purpose we completed a qualitative research study involving students enrolled in different types of organic chemistry course sections at our university. Our analysis led to the identification of four distinct mental models, some of which resembled scientific models of acids and acid strength. However, the distinct models are better characterized as synthetic models that combined assumptions from one or more scientific models with intuitive beliefs about factors that determine the properties of chemical substances. For many students in our sample, mental models served more as tools for heuristic decision-making based on intuitively appealing, but many times mistaken, concept associations rather than as cognitive tools to generate explanations. Although many research participants used a single general mental model to complete all of the interview tasks, the presence of specific problem features or changes in the nature of the task (e.g., prediction vs. explanation) prompted several students to change their mental model or to add a different mental representation. Our study indicates that properly diversifying and sequencing the types of academic tasks in which students are asked to participate could better foster meaningful learning as different types of cognitive resources may be activated by different students, and thus shared, analyzed, and discussed. ß

Culturing reality: How organic chemistry graduate students develop into practitioners

“…Rather than making a priori assumptions regarding the students' experiences (Marton, ), this approach allowed the researchers to learn from the participants about issues that were most pertinent to them. Our research, therefore, adds to the expanding list of qualitative studies on the learning of organic chemistry at the university level (Anderson & Bodner, ; Bhattacharyya, ; Bhattacharyya & Bodner, ; Bowen, ; Bowen & Bodner, ; Cartrette & Bodner, ; Cartrette & Mayo, ; Christian & Talanquer, ; Ferguson & Bodner, ; Grove & Bretz, 2010, 2012; Grove, Hershbarger, & Bretz, ; Henderleiter, Smart, Anderson, & Elian, ; Kraft, Strickland, & Bhattacharyya, ; McClary & Talanquer, ; Raker & Towns, ; Rushton, Hardy, Gwaltney, & Lewis, ; Strickland, Kraft, & Bhattacharyya, ).…”

Wie wirken elektronische Substituenteneffekte? – Entwicklung eines konzeptbasierten Zugangs durch Inventing with Contrasting Cases am Modellbeispiel der alkalischen Esterhydrolyse

“…Diesezeigen, dass viele Studierendedie Acidität organischerSäuren nichtanhandder -m aßgeblich vonmesomerenu nd induktiven Effekten beeinflussten-Stabilitätd er korrespondierenden Base beurteilen bzw. Auch wenn siem it derS tabilitätd er korrespondierenden Base argumentieren, denE influssd ieserE ffektee rkennenu nd diek orrekten Schlussfolgerungen ziehen,erfolgt dies vielfach überverkürzte Heuristikena nstellef achgerechter Erklärungen [4,5]. Dabein utzens ie häufig isolierte Fakten, Regeln undK onzepte, anstatte inen multivaria-tenE rklärungsansatzz uv erfolgen [3,5].…”

“…Insbesondere derm esomere Effekt spielt in diesem Zusammenhang eine entscheidende Rolle, handeltessichhierbei doch um ein übergeordnetes, für dasV erständnisder OrganischenChemiefundamentales Konzept.E rkenntnisse zu VorstellungenS tudierenderv on der Wirkungsweisee lektronischerS ubstituenteneffektez eigen jedoch,dassdiese oftmalsfehlerhaft [1],verkürzt [2,3,4] und/ oder aufe inen bestimmten Kontextl imitiert sind [5]. Durchg ezieltes Einführen vonSubstituenten mitmesomerem und/oder induk-tivemE ffektk annd ie Aktivierung bzw.…”

Learning from Children’s Drawings of Nature

“…I asked for drawings with the assumption that children have an inner representation, a mental model, as their understanding of a phenomenon (Moseley et al, 2010;Greca & Moreira, 2000;Shepardson et al, 2007;McClary & Talanquer, 2011). This model is constructed from one's conceptions and experiences and may change over time with new experience and knowledge.…”