Sex determination, the step at which differentiation of males and females is initiated in the embryo, is of central importance to the propagation of species. There is a remarkable diversity of mechanisms by which sex determination is accomplished. In general these mechanisms fall into two categories: Genetic Sex Determination (GSD), which depends on genetic differences between the sexes, and Environmental Sex Determination (ESD), which depends on extrinsic cues. In this review we will consider these two means of determining sex with particular emphasis on two species: a species that depends on GSD, Mus musculus, and a species that depends on ESD, Trachemys scripta. Because the structural organization of the adult testis and ovary is very similar across vertebrates, most biologists had expected that the pathways downstream of the sexdetermining switch would be conserved. However, emerging data indicate that not only are the initial sex determining mechanisms different, but the downstream pathways and morphogenetic events leading to the development of a testis or ovary also are different.
Keywordsgonad; mouse; sex determination; turtle
Mechanisms of sex determinationIn GSD, sex is determined by genetic differences between individuals in the population. These may involve heteromorphic sex chromosomes or chromsomal regions, dosage differences of chromosomes or genes, or the cumulative effect of multiple variable alleles in the genome. The most familiar example of heteromorphic sex chromosomes is the case in humans, where males carry one X and one Y chromosome, and females carry two X chromosomes. This is the system employed by all mammals with the exception of a few species (1). In mammals it is clear that a single gene on the Y chromosome, Sry, is responsible for male sex determination (2, 3) (Fig. 1A) Birds also utilize a system of heteromorphic sex chromosomes. However, in contrast to mammals, female birds are the heterogametic sex, carrying one W and one Z chromosome, while males are homogametic (ZZ) (6). In birds no genetic locus regulating sex determination is yet known. Because investigations of birds with sex chromosome aneuploidy have been inconclusive, it is not clear whether sex determination results from the presence of two Z chromosomes or the absence of a W chromosome. In fact evidence suggests that it might be a combination of both mechanisms (7,8). In other species, where heteromorphic chromosomal regions have not been identified between the sexes, it has been proposed that sex is a multigenic trait that is controlled by the cumulative effect of a number of allelic variants segregating in the population at different loci. This is the case in the housefly, Musca (9).Many animals depend on extrinsic factors to determine their sex. Environmental sex determination (ESD) can depend on a wide range of influences including temperature, visual cues, population cues, or hormone activities (10-12). These mechanisms would not work for mammals where both sexes develop under constant temperature and hormo...