“…The extent of protection also changes with the feeding style of the attacking herbivore. Arbuscular mycorrhiza symbiosis seems to benefit phloem-sucking insects (aphids) (Gange et al, 1999;Koricheva et al, 2009), while effects on chewing and leaf-mining insects are largely adverse (Gange and West, 1994;Vicari et al, 2002;Hoffmann et al, 2009); counter-examples, however, also exist (Babikova et al, 2014b;Shrivastava et al, 2015). This considerable variation can be ascribed to some extent to the species (plant, fungus and herbivore) involved in the tripartite interactions (Bennett and Bever, 2007;Gange, 2007;Leitner et al, 2010;Pineda et al, 2010).…”