Host orientation by two nitidulid beetles was compared: Stelidota geminata (Say), which is very broad in its' host range, and Stelidota octomaculata (Say), a species whose feeding is restricted primarily to acorns. In a no‐choice assay, both species responded to all food substrates offered and neither showed a significant preference among substrates (except banana versus wood fungi for S. octomaculata), or between aseptic and inoculated treatments; however, S. geminata readily displayed both phototactic flights and host‐orienting flights, whereas S. octomaculata never exhibited phototactic flight and never responded to food odors by flying to the source. Furthermore, when upwind‐walking response was compared, S. octomaculata walked to the source at a rate of 0.16 ± 0.01 cm/s, which was significantly lower than that of S. geminata, with a rate of 0.54 ± 0.02 cm/s. Turning frequency on the way to the source also differed between the two species, whereas distance traveled, number of pauses, and duration of pauses did not differ significantly. We submit that both species represent ‘olfactory generalists’, and that the restricted host range of S. octomaculata compared to S. geminata is not mediated by differences in long‐range response to host odors, but rather is due to differences in other behaviors such as a reduced rate of locomotion, post‐landing behavior, and possibly ecological factors.