Community, intervention and provider support influences on implementation: reflections from a South African illustration of safety, peace and health promotion

Abstract

BackgroundThe development, implementation and evaluation of community interventions are important for reducing child violence and injuries in low- to middle-income contexts, with successful implementation critical to effective intervention outcomes. The assessment of implementation processes is required to identify the factors that influence effective implementation. This article draws on a child safety, peace and health initiative to examine key factors that enabled or hindered its implementation, in a context characterised by limited resources.MethodsA case study approach was employed. The research team was made up of six researchers and intervention coordinators, who led the development and implementation of the Ukuphepha Child Study in South Africa, and who are also the authors of this article. The study used author observations, reflections and discussions of the factors perceived to influence the implementation of the intervention. The authors engaged in an in-depth and iterative dialogic process aimed at abstracting the experiences of the intervention, with a recursive cycle of reflection and dialogue. Data were analysed utilising inductive content analysis, and categorised using classification frameworks for understanding implementation.ResultsThe study highlights key factors that enabled or hindered implementation. These included the community context and concomitant community engagement processes; intervention compatibility and adaptability issues; community service provider perceptions of intervention relevance and expectations; and the intervention support system, characterised by training and mentorship support.ConclusionsThis evaluation illustrated the complexity of intervention implementation. The study approach sought to support intervention fidelity by fostering and maintaining community endorsement and support, a prerequisite for the unfolding implementation of the intervention.

A multilevel analysis of the relationship between neighborhood social disorder and depressive symptoms: Evidence from the South African National Income Dynamics Study.

“…Residential areas in South Africa continue to undergo dynamic changes in socioeconomic, class, and racial composition (Schensul & Heller, 2011). We call for more research, specifically longitudinal spatial studies, to examine this dynamic association between neighborhood social disorder and depressive symptoms, while addressing the design and implementation concerns of community-based interventions in South Africa (Whitehead, Kriel, & Richter, 2005; van Niekerk et al, 2014).…”

Cross-cultural adaptation of an anxiety measure in a disadvantaged South African community context: Methodological processes and findings

“…The assumptions that translators are equipped to identify flaws in adaptation, that welltranslated measures guarantee cross-cultural validity of scores and that field testing is mostly unnecessary, should be challenged and corrected by the addition of robust expert and community-based consultation relating to translated and CCA items (Hambleton & Patsula, 1999;Hambleton & Lee, 2013). Although community-based participatory research has a strong history in transcultural research and has been championed in research positioned towards social justice in the South African context (Lazarus, Bulbulia, Taliep, & Naidoo, 2015;Van Niekerk et al, 2014;Tindana et al, 2015;Ismail, 2018), its application remains limited.…”

Building Partnership to Improve Migrants’ Access to Healthcare in Mumbai

“…The contextual factors and their weaker social networks prevented them from participating in any community-level activity. The vulnerability and marginalization pose as barriers in community participation and have been documented in an African study ( 42 ).…”