Comparison of Fixation Techniques of 3D-Woven Poly(ϵ-Caprolactone) Scaffolds for Cartilage Repair in a Weightbearing Porcine Large Animal Model

Abstract

Objective To test different fixation methods of a 3-dimensionally woven poly(ϵ-caprolactone) (PCL) scaffold within chondral defects of a weightbearing large animal model. Methods Full thickness chondral defects were made in the femoral condyles of 15 adult male Yucatan mini-pigs. Two surgical approaches were compared including total arthrotomy (traditional) and a retinaculum-sparing, minimally invasive surgery (MIS) approach. Following microfracture (MFX), scaffolds were placed without fixation or were fixed with fibrin glue, suture, or subchondral anchor. Experimental endpoints were between 1 and 6 weeks. Micro-computed tomography and histology were used to assess samples. Results The MIS approach was superior as the traditional approach caused medial condyle cartilage wear. One of 13 (7.7%) of scaffolds without fixation, 4 of 11 (36.3%) fibrin scaffolds, 1 of 4 (25%) of sutured scaffolds, and 9 of 9 (100%) of anchor-fixed scaffolds remained in place. Histology demonstrated tissue filling with some overgrowth of PCL scaffolds. Conclusions Of the methods tested, the MIS approach coupled with subchondral anchor fixation provided the best scaffold retention in a mini-pig chondral defect model. This finding has implications for fixation strategies in future animal studies and potential future human use.

Infiltration and In-Tissue Polymerization of Photocross-Linked Hydrogel for Effective Fixation of Implants into Cartilage—An In Vitro Study

“…7,8 One reason for the unsatisfactory results of implantation surgeries can be the insufficiency of fixing the implants. 9…”

A Porcine Model of Peripheral Nerve Injury Enabling Ultra-Long Regenerative Distances: Surgical Approach, Recovery Kinetics, and Clinical Relevance

“…Unlike other widely used models, porcine subjects are particularly well suited as a pre-clinical model because the nerves are remarkably similar to humans. 33 Moreover, the similar physiology between humans and porcine have resulted in its increasing popularity as a preclinical translational research model in various areas, such as traumatic brain injury, [34][35][36][37][38][39][40] spinal cord injury, 41 wound healing, 42 cartilage repair, [43][44][45][46][47] intervertebral disc herniation, 48 coronary artery injury, 49 and gastrointestinal, 50 and hepatic surgery. 51 Indeed, the objective in the development of the porcine model presented in this study was to replicate critical features of extremely challenging repair and regeneration scenarios following major PNI in human.…”

Emerging therapies for cartilage regeneration in currently excluded ‘red knee’ populations

“…Initial scaffold attempts used simple sponges and hydrogels with moduli (both instantaneous and equilibrium) in the tens of kilopascals (kPa), while the modulus of native cartilage is 20–50 times higher. More recently, groups have utilized a variety of fabrication (weaving, 62,79 3D printing, 56,80,81 casting 57,63 ) and cross-linking (UV photoinitiator, 82,83 EDC crosslinking, 83–85 dehydrothermal treatment 83 ) techniques to improve the mechanical properties of the time-zero scaffold (Fig. 4—red squares and triangles).…”