“…Despite the long history of TID observation, the generic relationship between f o F 2 and h m (as well as virtual height) discussed in this paper has only occasionally been recognized [e.g., Vlasov et al ., ; Shiokawa et al ., ; Liu et al ., ] and the relationship of these parameters with the subpeak thickness y m , while previously reported [ Ashkaliev et al ., ; Yakovets et al ., , , , ; Pezzopane et al ., ], continues to remain little known in the ionospheric community.…”