Comparison of walking overground and in a Computer Assisted Rehabilitation Environment (CAREN) in individuals with and without transtibial amputation

Abstract

BackgroundDue to increased interest in treadmill gait training, recent research has focused on the similarities and differences between treadmill and overground walking. Most of these studies have tested healthy, young subjects rather than impaired populations that might benefit from such training. These studies also do not include optic flow, which may change how the individuals integrate sensory information when walking on a treadmill. This study compared overground walking to treadmill walking in a computer assisted virtual reality environment (CAREN) in individuals with and without transtibial amputations (TTA).MethodsSeven individuals with traumatic TTA and 27 unimpaired controls participated. Subjects walked overground and on a treadmill in a CAREN at a normalized speed. The CAREN applied optic flow at the same speed that the subject walked. Temporal-spatial parameters, full body kinematics, and kinematic variability were collected during all trials.ResultsBoth subject groups decreased step time and control subjects decreased step length when walking in the CAREN. Differences in lower extremity kinematics were small (< 2.5○) and did not exceed the minimal detectable change values for these measures. Control subjects exhibited decreased transverse and frontal plane range of motion of the pelvis and trunk when walking in the CAREN, while patients with TTA did not. Both groups exhibited increased step width variability during treadmill walking in the CAREN, but only minor changes in kinematic variability.ConclusionsThe results of this study suggest that treadmill training in a virtual environment should be similar enough to overground that changes should carry over. Caution should be made when comparing step width variability and step time results from studies utilizing a treadmill to those overground.

Does unilateral transtibial amputation lead to greater metabolic demand during walking?

“…There are several examples in which servicemembers who participated in intensive rehabilitation programs and had access to regular prosthetic care demonstrated smaller deficits than previously reported. For example, they have performed similarly to their nondisabled counterparts in areas such as activity performance, gait biomechanics, and walking stability [34][35][36][37][38][39][40][41]. It is important to recognize that the similarities observed here and elsewhere, while encouraging, do not represent an absence of dysfunction or the full restoration of function in all people or across all aspects of life.…”

A Pilot Study of the VirtuSphere as a Virtual Reality Enhancement

“…Our preliminary findings should not be construed as a general criticism of the potential utility of more realistic locomotion interfaces in other clinical VR systems. For example, there is some evidence that treadmill interfaces in VR may prove useful for gait training (Darter & Wilken, 2011;Gates, Darter, Dingwell, & Wilken, 2012).…”

Is faster always better? The walking speed-dependency of gait variability in bilateral vestibulopathy

“…To ensure correct muscle contraction, a feedback system using a screen was provided. An average of 200 EMG traces with a minimum mean rectified voltage (MRV) of 65µV and a maximum MRV of 205µV was accepted (Brantberg and Lofqvist 2007;Fujimoto et al 2009). The oVEMP was recorded at the contralateral inferior oblique muscle.…”