Flexible
metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are of high interest
as smart programmable materials for gas sorption due to their unique
structural changes triggered by external stimuli. Owing to this property,
which leads to opportunities such as maximizing deliverable gas capacity,
flexible MOFs sometimes offer more advantages in sorption applications
compared to their more rigid counterparts. Herein, we elucidate the
effect of transition metal identity of a series of isonicotinate-based
flexible MOFs, M(4-PyC)2 [MMg, Mn, and Cu; 4-PyC
= 4-pyridine carboxylic acid] on the structural dynamic response to
different gases (C2H4, C2H6, Xe, Kr, and SO2). Isotherms at different temperatures
show that C2H4, C2H6,
and Xe can form sufficiently strong interactions with both Mg(4-PyC)2 and Mn(4-PyC)2 frameworks resulting in gate-opening
behavior due to the rotation of the linker’s pyridine ring,
while Kr cannot induce this phenomenon for the two MOFs under the
measured conditions. In contrast, the gate-opening behavior occurs
for Cu(4-PyC)2 solely in the presence of C2H4, and no other measured gas, due to the open metal sites of
Cu centers. In comparison, SO2, a strong polar molecule,
triggers the gate-opening effect in all three MOFs. Interestingly,
a shape memory effect is observed for Cu(4-PyC)2 during
the second SO2 sorption cycle. When comparing the different
gate-opening pressures of each gas, we observed that the structural
flexibility of the three frameworks is highly sensitive to the chemical
hardness of the Lewis acidic metal ions (Mg2+ > Mn2+ > Cu2+). As a result, the gate opening behavior
is observed at lower pressures for the MOFs containing weaker M–N
bonds (harder metal ions), with the exception of Cu(4-PyC)2 toward C2H4. These observations reveal that
different transition metals can be used to finely control the structural
flexibility of the frameworks.