Atomistic spin model simulations are immensely useful in determining temperature dependent magnetic properties, but are known to give the incorrect dependence of the magnetization on temperature compared to experiment owing to their classical origin. We find a single parameter rescaling of thermal fluctuations which gives quantitative agreement of the temperature dependent magnetization between atomistic simulations and experiment for the elemental ferromagnets Ni, Fe , Co and Gd. Simulating the sub-picosecond magnetization dynamics of Ni under the action of a laser pulse we also find quantitative agreement with experiment in the ultrafast regime. This enables the quantitative determination of temperature dependent magnetic properties allowing for accurate simulations of magnetic materials at all temperatures.