Consumers’ evaluation of allocation policies for scarce health care services: Vested interest activation trumps spatial and temporal distance

Abstract

The allocation of scarce health care service resources often requires tradeoffs between individual and collective outcomes (e.g., when some individuals benefit more strongly from a given policy than others). Based on construal level theory, one would expect that consumers cognitively represent the individual and collective outcomes of an allocation policy at different levels of abstraction and that they evaluate allocation policies more positively when there is congruency between the cognitive representation of the policy's focal outcome and the spatial and temporal distance inherently present in the policy's decision context (e.g., allocation decisions on a future policy). However, we hypothesize that this congruency effect can be overruled by a high vested interest mindset that is activated by an individual's recent personal experience with a health care service provider. Since a high vested interest mindset increases the relevance of the allocation policy implementation for the individual because s/he perceives strong personal consequences, we propose that for consumers with recent experience the evaluation of an allocation policy that focuses on individual outcomes is higher than that of a policy that focuses on collective outcomes irrespective of the spatial and temporal distance in the decision

Promote Health or Prevent Disease? The Effects of Health-Related Advertising on Eating Behavior Intention

“…The result of the between-subject effects of regulatory focus and graphics-text ratio on attitude toward the ads and behavior were statistically significant. Our results were consistent with previous research that reported that individuals with promotion focus preferred a high construal level, which indicates that they preferred abstract advertisements, and vice versa [ 23 , 37 ]. However, we determined that the interaction effects of regulatory focus and the graphics-text ratio were both directional and statistically significant when the manipulation was promotion focus.…”

“…We investigated the interaction effect of temporal distance and the graphics-text ratio and found that the difference of behavior and attitude toward ads was bigger when the temporal distance was set as “in one year” than “in one month”. We surmised that this lack of significance could have occurred because the average age of participants in this study was approximately 27 years, which is too young to have sufficient knowledge regarding colorectal cancer, whereas the participants in previous studies were approximately 40 years or older [ 37 , 38 ].…”

Construal Level Theory of Mobile Persuasion

“…Neural connections in the brain are arranged accordingly, with more abstract renderings located ''at higher points in the cortical hierarchy'' , p. 1204. Therefore, when psychological distance and construal level are congruent (close and low; far and high), cognitive processing is more fluent (Benning, Breugelmans, & Dellaert, 2012;Kim, Rao, & Lee, 2009) than when they are incongruent (close and high; far and low). This fluency has been illustrated through studies using implicit association tests; congruent pairings (close and low; far and high) were matched faster than incongruent ones (close and high; far and low; Bar-anan et al, 2006).…”

An Examination of Construal Effects on Price Perceptions in the Advance Selling of Experience Services

“…Armed with this knowledge, experienced buyers should construe that prices will decline over time such that lower prices are typically worth the search whether the event is coming sooner or later. Benning, Breugelmans, and Dellaert (2012) find that recent experience overruled temporal distance effects when considering health-care services. Kyung, Menon, and Trope (2014) show that those more experienced and knowledgeable more easily retrieve judgments, and this fluency or salience moderates temporal distance effects.…”