Content analysis of UK newspaper and online news representations of women's and men's ‘binge’ drinking: a challenge for communicating evidence-based messages about single-episodic drinking?

Abstract

ObjectivesIn the UK, men's alcohol-related morbidity and mortality still greatly exceeds women's, despite an increase in women's alcohol consumption in recent decades. New UK alcohol guidelines introduce gender-neutral low-risk alcohol consumption guidance. This study explores how UK newspaper and online news represent women's and men's ‘binge’ drinking to identify opportunities to better align reporting of harmful drinking with evidence.DesignQuantitative and qualitative content analysis of 308 articles published in 7 UK national newspapers and the BBC News website between 1 January 2012 and 31 December 2013.ResultsArticles associated women with ‘binge’ drinking more frequently than men, and presented women's drinking as more problematic. Men were more frequently characterised as violent or disorderly, while women were characterised as out of control, putting themselves in danger, harming their physical appearance and burdening men. Descriptions of female ‘binge’ drinkers' clothing and appearance were typically moralistic.ConclusionsThe UK news media's disproportionate focus on women's ‘binge’ drinking is at odds with epidemiological evidence, may reproduce harmful gender stereotypes and may obstruct public understandings of the gender-neutral weekly consumption limits in newly proposed alcohol guidelines. In order to better align reporting of harmful drinking with current evidence, public health advocates may engage with the media with a view to shifting media framing of ‘binge’ drinking away from specific groups (young people; women) and contexts (public drinking) and towards the health risks of specific drinking behaviours, which affect all groups regardless of context.

The role of alcohol in constructing gender & class identities among young women in the age of social media

“…Despite young women reporting pleasure from their drinking, there remains a gendered double standard around their consumption practices ( Atkinson & Sumnall, 2016 ; de Visser & McDonnell, 2012 ). There is a disproportionate emphasis on women’s ‘binge’ drinking in the media which is often framed as an attempt to emulate men and as transgressing traditional gender roles ( Day, Gough, & McFadden, 2004 ; Jackson & Tinkler, 2007 ; Lyons, Dalton, & Hoy, 2006 ; Measham & Østergaard, 2009 ; Patterson, Emslie, Mason, Fergie, & Hilton, 2016 ). While women’s drinking may now be considered socially acceptable, drunk women continue to elicit reactions of visceral repulsion (e.g.…”

Is there gender convergence in risky drinking when taking birth cohorts into account? Evidence from an Australian national survey 2001–13

“…Women's drinking, and especially heavy drinking, generates disproportionate media interest , which often relies on particularly stigmatizing discussions of women's drinking , so it is important to develop a nuanced understanding of trends in consumption throughout genders in Australia. In this study, we use data from five waves of Australia's largest alcohol and other drug survey conducted between 2001 and 2013 to examine whether or not there has been gender convergence in risky drinking in Australia in recent years.…”

UK news media representations of smoking, smoking policies and tobacco bans in prisons

“…Our main analytical method was inductive thematic analysis, a subjective process conducted to identify the latent (less directly observable) content. 37 39 All authors independently developed a draft coding frame over a series of stages, with AR reading all and, between them, HS/KH almost all (95%) of articles. Iterative discussion and several stages of exploratory double/triple coding finalised the coding frame and identification of four broad thematic categories: smoking in prisons; smoking bans in prison; broader aspects and country of reference.…”