Anagostic C−H•••M (M = a metal center) intramolecular interactions, one of the most fundamental and elusive forces in organometallic chemistry, are intuitively considered as repulsive and purely electrostatic in nature because of significant metal−hydrogen distances (∼2.3−3.0 Å). Contrary to the current state of knowledge, it is shown herein by quantum chemical computations based on the case study of new square-planar Ni II isomers based on Nthiophosphorylated thiourea that despite significant metal− hydrogen anagostic distances, the covalent-type charge delocalization contribution [Ni(d z 2 ) → σ*(C−H) and σ(C− H) → Ni(d z 2)] exists and it covers, together with the London dispersion energy, up to ∼40% of the overall anagostic stabilization. This charge delocalization component is found to amplify the metalloaromaticity phenomenon although a lack of any stabilizing charge transfer is expected at such long metalhydrogen distances (>3 Å). Remarkably, for the relatively short regime (<3 Å) of anagostic distances, the electrostatic Coulomb forces are destabilizing, which leads to the repulsive anagostic interactions, whereas, surprisingly, an increase of anagostic distance above 3 Å makes anagostic interactions stabilizing mostly because of attractive Coulomb forces. It shows unprecedented agostic (attractive) ↔ anagostic (repulsive) transitions in ubiquitous d 8 square-planar Ni II complexes containing elongated metal−hydrogen distances.