“…In a recent scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) study of Co grown on Al 2 O 3 /NiAl(100), it was reported that a large fraction of Co nanoparticles can survive long time annealing at 1090 K. 3 Persistence of Co nanoparticles at such high temperature is certainly very desirable as it increases the temperature limit of stable operation. However, other studies of similar systems 6,7,14 and, in particular, our own Auger study of the same system all indicated that metal nanoparticles grown on a thin layer of oxide will sinter slightly and then completely diffuse into the NiAl substrate below 1000 K. Thus, for reasons unknown, the oxide films in Ref.…”