The truncated/VH-less mouse H chain Dμ forms precursor B cell receptors with the surrogate L chain complex that promotes allelic exclusion but not other aspects of pre-B cell development, causing most progenitor B cells expressing this H chain to be eliminated at the pre-B cell checkpoint. However, there is evidence that Dμ-λ1 complexes can be made and are positively selected during fetal life but cannot sustain adult B lymphopoiesis. How surrogate and conventional L chains interpret Dμ’s unusual structure and how that affects signaling outcome are unclear. Using nonlymphoid and primary mouse B cells, we show that secretion-competent λ1 L chains could associate with both full-length H chains and Dμ, whereas secretion-incompetent λ1 L chains could only do so with full-length H chains. In contrast, Dμ could not form receptors with a panel of κ L chains irrespective of their secretion properties. This was due to an incompatibility of Dμ with the κ-joining and constant regions. Finally, the Dμ-λ1 receptor was less active than the full-length mouse μ-λ1 receptor in promoting growth under conditions of limiting IL-7. Thus, multiple receptor-dependent mechanisms operating at all stages of B cell development limit the contribution of B cells with Dμ H chain alleles to the repertoire.