Lensfree holographic microscopy is a compact and cost-effective modality for imaging large fields of view with high resolution. When combined with automated image processing, it can be used for biomolecular sensing where biochemically functionalized micro- and nano-beads are used to label biomolecules of interest. Neural networks for image feature classification provide faster and more robust sensing results than traditional image processing approaches. While neural networks have been widely applied to other types of image classification problems, and even image reconstruction in lensfree holographic microscopy, it is unclear what type of network architecture performs best for the types of small object image classification problems involved in holographic-based sensors. Here, we apply a shallow convolutional neural network to this task, and thoroughly investigate how different layers and hyperparameters affect network performance. Layers include dropout, convolutional, normalization, pooling, and activation. Hyperparameters include dropout fraction, filter number and size, stride, and padding. We ultimately achieve a network accuracy of ∼83%, and find that the choice of activation layer is most important for maximizing accuracy. We hope that these results can be helpful for researchers developing neural networks for similar classification tasks.