The selectivity of four small-pore silicoaluminophosphate molecular sieves, including , , , and SAPO-18 (AEI), toward light olefins in general and ethylene in particular has been investigated for the methanol-to-olefins reaction using gas chromatography. This study was prompted by earlier electron spin resonance and electron spin-echo modulation results on nickel-modified SAPO materials in which Ni(I) was incorporated into both framework and ion-exchanged sites. These seemingly similar materials behaved significantly differently with respect to reducing agents and adsorbates. Attention was focused on whether the catalyst performance is influenced by the structural type, the presence of a transition metal ion (Ni) either in the framework or at ion-exchanged positions, or the amount of incorporated transition metal ion. Our results show that these factors indeed play an important role in the catalytic behavior. Among the protonated H-SAPO-n materials, the highest combined distribution of ethylene, propylene, and butenes (C 2 -C 4 olefins) was obtained with H-SAPO-34, and the lowest with H-SAPO-35, which also had the shortest lifetime for catalytic activity. H-SAPO-18 turned out to be the best catalyst in terms of lifetime for catalytic activity. Incorporation of Ni(II) into the framework increased the lifetime, the overall distribution of C 2 -C 4 olefins (in the case of NiAPSO-34), and the selectivity of the catalysts toward ethylene (in the cases of , whereas incorporation of Ni(II) by means of solid-state ion exchange (NiH-SAPO-n) increased only the selectivity toward ethylene. Also, the increase in ethylene selectivity was more prominent in synthesized than in ion-exchanged samples. Among the Ni-loaded samples, NiAPSO-34 was found to be the best catalyst in terms of both ethylene selectivity and lifetime, whereas NiH-SAPO-18 exhibited the worst ethylene yield and NiH-SAPO-35 the shortest lifetime. Finally, the effect of the amount of Ni was investigated in NiAPSO-34. It appears that the selectivity toward ethylene does not increase linearly with NiAPSO samples prepared with an increasing amount of Ni in the reaction gel. In fact, there seems to be an optimum Ni concentration for which ethylene selectivity reaches a maximum and above which ethylene selectivity decreases. This optimum concentration is the same as was found in earlier studies to yield the strongest Ni(I) signal, as observed by ESR.