Cooperative binding mitigates the high-dose hook effect

Abstract

BackgroundThe high-dose hook effect (also called prozone effect) refers to the observation that if a multivalent protein acts as a linker between two parts of a protein complex, then increasing the amount of linker protein in the mixture does not always increase the amount of fully formed complex. On the contrary, at a high enough concentration range the amount of fully formed complex actually decreases. It has been observed that allosterically regulated proteins seem less susceptible to this effect. The aim of this study was two-fold: First, to investigate the mathematical basis of how allostery mitigates the prozone effect. And second, to explore the consequences of allostery and the high-dose hook effect using the example of calmodulin, a calcium-sensing protein that regulates the switch between long-term potentiation and long-term depression in neurons.ResultsWe use a combinatorial model of a “perfect linker protein” (with infinite binding affinity) to mathematically describe the hook effect and its behaviour under allosteric conditions. We show that allosteric regulation does indeed mitigate the high-dose hook effect. We then turn to calmodulin as a real-life example of an allosteric protein. Using kinetic simulations, we show that calmodulin is indeed subject to a hook effect. We also show that this effect is stronger in the presence of the allosteric activator Ca 2+/calmodulin-dependent kinase II (CaMKII), because it reduces the overall cooperativity of the calcium-calmodulin system. It follows that, surprisingly, there are conditions where increased amounts of allosteric activator actually decrease the activity of a protein.ConclusionsWe show that cooperative binding can indeed act as a protective mechanism against the hook effect. This will have implications in vivo where the extent of cooperativity of a protein can be modulated, for instance, by allosteric activators or inhibitors. This can result in counterintuitive effects of decreased activity with increased concentrations of both the allosteric protein itself and its allosteric activators.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12918-017-0447-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Bivalent Ligands for Protein Degradation in Drug Discovery

“…It is an intrinsic property of the PROTAC mode of action, and has significant impact on dosing strategies. However, computational methods suggest that cooperativity of binding can mitigate or reduce the hook effect [ 42 , 43 ]. In the context of PROTAC, cooperativity means that binding of the bivalent molecule to one protein increases the affinity for the second protein, skewing the equilibrium from the formation of binary complexes to the desired ternary complex.…”

Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) in cancer therapy

“…In this circumstance, the right equilibrium is not achieved, since elevated PROTAC concentrations would saturate binding sites on the E3 ligase on one side and on the protein target on the other side, exhausting free forms of these proteins that could be used for ternary complexes. This process, produced when high concentrations of the PROTAC are present, is called the “hook effect” [ 58 , 59 ]. It is relevant to mention that some PROTACs such as MZ1 may mitigate the hook effect as they exhibit positive cooperativity with respect to the assembly of ternary complexes.…”

Bifunctional chemical probes inducing protein–protein interactions

“…Dimerization can be for molecules of the same protein (homo-dimerizer) or different proteins (hetero-dimerizer). Formation of the desired ternary complex is more productive when the dimerizer binds one protein more tightly in the presence of the other protein rather than its absence -a thermodynamic characteristics of ternary equilibria known as cooperativity [9][10][11][12].…”