Cation−π interactions play important roles in various biological systems. Recently, cation−π interactions have been suggested to have considerable roles in mussel adhesion, which is the most well-known biological model for underwater adhesion. Although amine−catechol pair synergy in mussel adhesion has been well studied for surface adhesion in the aqueous phase, little is known about its effect on cohesion, particularly in intermolecular cation−π interactions. Here, we designed musselinspired model peptides to characterize the amine−catechol pair effect on cation−π interactions. We used nanomechanics to measure the interaction directly and probed cation−π interactions with nuclear magnetic resonance and Raman spectroscopy. Moreover, we established the origins of these effects through intensive Raman spectra analysis. We discovered that amine−catechol pairs have antisynergetic effects on intermolecular cation−π interactions, and this finding may provide the insight that the amine−catechol pair synergy may not always work on the positive side in underwater adhesion.