Coproduction and trust in government: evidence from survey experiments

Kang, Sinah; Ryzin, Gregg G. Van

doi:10.1080/14719037.2019.1619812

Cited by 36 publications

(23 citation statements)

References 50 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Previous studies mainly focused on trust in government as a dependent variable and analyzed the factors influencing it (Song and Lee, 2016;Porumbescu, 2016;Kang and Van Ryzin, 2019). The measure of trust in government was measured by "how much trust you have with government."…”

Section: Theoretical Discussion and Hypothesesmentioning

confidence: 99%

Trust in police as an influencing factor on trust in government: 2SLS analysis using perception of safety

Jisu

Han

2020

PIJPSM

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

PurposeCitizen trust in police is important in terms of citizen consent to government policies and of police achieving their organizational goals. In the previous study, improvements in police policy, organizational operation and policing activities were developed to clarify which factors influence trust in police and how trust can be improved. This research raises the question, would changes in trust in police have an impact on trust in government? In this paper, this research question is discussed theoretically and the causal relationship analyzed empirically by applying OLS, ordered logistic, 2SLS and logistic regressions.Design/methodology/approachThe basic analysis methods are to apply the OLS and the ordered logistic regression. OLS regression analysis is an analytical method that minimizes an error range of a regression line. The assumptions for OLS are: linearity, independence, equilibrium, extrapolation and multicollinearity issues. These problems were statistically verified and analyzed, in order to confirm the robustness of the analysis results by comparing the results of the ordered logistic regression because of the sequence characteristic of the dependent variable. The data to be used in this study is the Asia Barometer Survey in 2013.FindingsTrust in police and citizen perception of safety are analyzed as important factors to increase trust in the government. The effects of trust in police are more significant than the effects of control variables, and the direction and strength of the results are stable. The effect of trust in police on trust in government is strengthened by the perception of safety (IV). In addition, OLS, ordered logistic regression analysis, which analyzed trust in central government and local government, and logistic regression analysis categorized by trust and distrust show the stability.Research limitations/implicationsThis paper has implications in terms of theoretical and empirical analysis of the relationship between trust in police and trust in government. In addition, the impact of perception of safety on trust in police can be provided to police officers, policymakers and governors who are seeking to increase trust in government. This paper is also meaningful in that it is the microscopic research based on the citizens' survey. One of the limitations of macroscopic research is that it does not consider the individual perceptions of citizens.Practical implicationsThe results of this paper can confirm the relationship of the virtuous cycle, which is perception of safety – trust in police – trust in government. The police will need to provide security services to improve citizens' perception of safety and make great efforts to create safer communities and society. Trust in police formed through this process can be an important component of trust in government. By making citizens feel safer and achieving trust in police, ultimately, trust in government will be improved.Originality/valueThe police perform one of the essential roles of government and are one of the major components of trust in government, but the police sector has been neglected compared to the roles of the economic and political sectors. These influences of macro factors are too abstract to allow specific policy directions to be suggested. If we consider trust in police, and factors that can improve trust in government, we can suggest practical policy alternatives.

show abstract

Section: Theoretical Discussion and Hypothesesmentioning

confidence: 99%

Trust in police as an influencing factor on trust in government: 2SLS analysis using perception of safety

Jisu

Han

2020

PIJPSM

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…If we follow Voorberg's (Voorberg, Bekkers, and Tummers 2015) lamentation that co-creation is overly focused on design and that there is a need to draw on the coproduction literature to understand the implementation of value co-creation, this is what the following three papers in this special issue (Alonso et al 2019;Kang and Van Ryzin 2019;Lember, Brandsen, and Tõnurist 2019) do in this special issue. Reporting on quantitative cross-sectional findings, Alonso et al (2019) put forward several co-production antecedents which could help us gain a nuanced understanding of when co-production is meaningfulin which services, with which clients.…”

Section: Papers In This Issuementioning

confidence: 94%

Following the yellow brick road? (Dis)enchantment with co-design, co-production and value co-creation in public services

Dudau

Glennon

Verschuere

2019

Public Management Review

157

152

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

“…Também é possível que se constitua como um tipo de relação que pode acabar por destruir transparência, confiança, participação e accountability em decorrência da desconfiança do cidadão na capacidade do Estado de cumprir com as suas promessas e obrigações em relação à própria coprodução . Além disso, embora se espere que a coprodução, sob certas condições, gere sinergia (Ostrom, 1996), a depender de como o processo é conduzido, a coprodução pode diminui-la (Kang & Ryzin, 2019), destruindo valor público ao invés de adicioná-lo (Bovaird & Loeffler, 2013). Ademais, a coprodução será impraticável se não houver efetiva redistribuição do poder, o poder com em lugar do poder sobre de que trata Follett (Stout & Love, 2017) para que os cidadãos se sintam incluídos e influenciem as políticas públicas.…”

Section: Coprodução -Visão Integrativaunclassified

“…Em resumo, a coprodução como elemento central e objetivo final de um processo complexo, multifacetado e deliberado que pode servir como resposta ao desequilíbrio e ao conflito "improdutivo" (Stout & Love, 2017); à escassez de recursos e de legitimidade governamentais (Brandsen & Honingh, 2016), embora naturalmente envolva riscos (Bovaird & Loeffler, 2014;Brandsen et al, 2018;Kang & Ryzin, 2019), depende e influencia os elementos que lhes dão sustentação. Demanda e implementa a transparência em relação aos processos produtivos e seus resultados.…”

Section: Coprodução -Visão Integrativaunclassified

Elementos estruturantes para a realização da coprodução do bem público: uma visão integrativa

et al. 2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Resumo Neste artigo discute-se a realização da coprodução de bens e serviços público a partir de uma visão integrativa. Parte-se da proposição de que transparência, informação, confiança, participação e accountability são elementos estruturantes da coprodução. Sugere-se, a partir daí, uma visão integrativa desse fenômeno com base na abordagem de Mary Parker Follett, considerando as inter-relações desses elementos para fundamentar a necessária compreensão de um processo complexo, multifacetado e deliberado. Trata-se de um estudo teórico-analítico, combinando elementos indutivos e dedutivos, com abordagem qualitativa, por meio de revisão narrativa e revisão sistemática da produção acadêmica nacional e internacional. Como resultado, destaca-se que a coprodução de bens e serviços públicos é uma tarefa complexa assentada na perspectiva sistêmica da associação de indivíduos em grupo. Aponta-se, ainda, a presença de elementos inter-relacionados e demanda por coesão social, a qual pode ser tanto consequência como catalisadora desses elementos nos processos de coprodução.

show abstract

Coproduction and trust in government: evidence from survey experiments

Cited by 36 publications

References 50 publications

Trust in police as an influencing factor on trust in government: 2SLS analysis using perception of safety

Trust in police as an influencing factor on trust in government: 2SLS analysis using perception of safety

Following the yellow brick road? (Dis)enchantment with co-design, co-production and value co-creation in public services

Elementos estruturantes para a realização da coprodução do bem público: uma visão integrativa

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About