Coverage for Gender‐Affirming Voice Surgery and Therapy for Transgender Individuals

Abstract

Objectives/Hypothesis To determine insurance coverage for gender‐affirming surgery and voice therapy for individuals who seek to align their voice with their gender identity, and to analyze differences based on state‐by‐state transgender equality. Study Design Cross‐sectional study. Methods Policies from the top three commercial insurers per state in 2019 were reviewed. Coverage status was determined by web‐based search, telephone interviews, and email inquiries. A state‐by‐state equality score was calculated based on the number of laws and policies relating to the transgender community. Correlation between number of preauthorized procedures and state equality scores was assessed. Results Of the 150 insurance companies reviewed, only four (2.7%) held favorable policies, whereas 113 (75.8%) provided no coverage. Endoscopic surgery, open surgery, individual voice therapy, and group voice therapy interventions were equally excluded (n = 93, 62.4%). Coverage was not correlated with laws driving transgender equality (P = .782). Conclusions Gender‐affirming voice interventions are seldom covered by commercial insurance companies. Despite established medical necessity and years of experience in practice, gender‐affirming interventions for voice have not yet been fully considered by third‐party payors. Further investigation regarding cost‐effectiveness and treatment efficacy is warranted to improve insurance coverage of voice‐related gender‐affirming care. Level of Evidence NA Laryngoscope, 131:E896–E902, 2021

Addressing disparities in speech-language pathology and laryngology services with telehealth

“…The Kaiser Family Foundation's (2018) report on SLP services revealed that nine states do not cover these services, twelve states require a copay for these services, and twenty-one states have limitations in these practices. For example, gender affirming voice services, voice evaluations, and laryngeal function studies were not covered by most major insurance companies ( Devore et al., 2021 ). Governmental policy following the COVID-19 pandemic allowed for an expansion of telehealth services and includes audio, video and web communication services that are covered by Medicaid and private payers ( Ortega et al., 2020 ).…”

Gender-Affirming Voice Surgery: Considerations for Surgical Intervention

“…In general, access to voice therapy as well as voice surgery can be extremely limited by lack of insurance coverage. 9 It is thought that access to voice therapy may be better than surgery due to the limited number of surgeons offering pitch elevating surgery. Regardless, voice and communication specialists are well positioned to provide information and guidance to TGE individuals who express dissatisfaction with their voice and communication.…”