Cholesterol oxidation products (called oxysterols) are involved in many biological processes, showing both negative (e.g., neurodegenerative) and positive (e.g., antiviral and antimicrobial) effects. The physiological activity of oxysterols is undoubtedly closely related to their structure (i.e., the type and location of the additional polar group in the cholesterol skeleton). In this paper, we focus on determining how a seemingly minor structural change (introduction of a hydroxyl moiety at C(24), C(25), or C(27) in the isooctyl chain of cholesterol) affects the organization of the resulting molecules at the phase boundary. In our research, we supplemented the classic Langmuir monolayer technique, based on the surface pressure and electric surface potential isotherms, with microscopic (BAM) and spectroscopic (PM-IRRAS) techniques, as well as theoretical calculations (DFT and MD). This allowed us to show that 24-OH behaves more like cholesterol and forms stable, rigid monolayers. On the other hand, 27-OH, similar to 25-OH, undergoes the phase transition from monolayer to bilayer structures. Theoretical calculations enabled us to conclude that the formation of bilayers from 27-OH or 25-OH is possible due to the hydrogen bonding between adjacent oxysterol molecules. This observation may help to understand the factors responsible for the unique biological activity (including antiviral and antimicrobial) of 27-OH and 25-OH compared to other oxysterols.