Data Quality in an Information-Rich Environment: Canada as an Example

Abstract

This review evaluates the quality of available administrative data in the Canadian provinces, emphasizing the information needed to create integrated systems. We explicitly compare approaches to quality measurement, indicating where record linkage can and cannot substitute for more expensive record re-abstraction. Forty-nine original studies evaluating Canadian administrative data (registries, hospital abstracts, physician claims, and prescription drugs) are summarized in a structured manner. Registries, hospital abstracts, and physician files appear to be generally of satisfactory quality, though much work remains to be done. Data quality did not vary systematically among provinces. Primary data collection to check place of residence and longitudinal follow-up in provincial registries is needed. Promising initial checks of pharmaceutical data should be expanded. Because record linkage studies were ''conservative'' in reporting reliability, the reduction of time-consuming record re-abstraction appears feasible in many cases. Finally, expanding the scope of administrative data to study health, as well as health care, seems possible for some chronic conditions. The research potential of the information-rich environments being created highlights the importance of data quality.

Age Difference Explains Gender Difference in Cardiac Intervention Rates After Acute Myocardial Infarction

“…The analysis used a population-based cohort approach, including all residents age 40 or older identified in the anonymized administrative data housed at the manitoba Centre for Health Policy. This data system contains complete and validated health service records Age Difference Explains Gender Difference in Cardiac Intervention Rates After Acute Myocardial Infarction for virtually every resident of the province (Roos et al 2005). The Health Research Ethics Board of the university of manitoba approved this study as part of a larger project on gender differences in health and healthcare use (fransoo et al 2005).…”

Mental and Physical Health Outcomes in Parents of Children with Burn Injuries as Compared with Matched Controls

“…The validity and accuracy of these datasets was excellent and had been validated in previous studies [31]. The linkage of these databases was shown to have very high accuracy [32][33][34][35]. For example, the true error rate of an original linkage of deaths reported by Vital Statistics was less than 1% [32].…”

An administrative data algorithm to identify traumatic spinal cord injured patients: a validation study

“…The data quality of both the NRS and CIHI-DAD is maintained through variable verification, and audit-feedback; reabstraction studies have shown 480% agreement with coding elements. 7 Physician billing occurs through the OHIP, and surgical fee claims are expected to have a high sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV), as shown with other service payments. 8 Data analysis.…”