Abstract. Precipitation/humidity proxies are widely used to reconstruct the
historical East Asian summer monsoon (EASM) variations based on the
assumption that summer precipitation over eastern China is closely and stably
linked to the strength of EASM. However, whether the observed
EASM–precipitation relationship (e.g., increased precipitation with a
stronger EASM) was stable throughout the past remains unclear. In this
study, we used model outputs from the Paleoclimate Modelling Intercomparison Project
Phase III and Community Earth System Model to investigate the stability
of the EASM–precipitation relationship over the last millennium on different
timescales. The model results indicate that the EASM strength (defined as the
regionally averaged meridional wind) was enhanced in the Medieval Climate Anomaly
(MCA; ∼ 950–1250 AD), during which there was increased precipitation
over eastern China, and weakened during the Little Ice Age (LIA;
∼ 1500–1800 AD), during which there was decreased precipitation,
consistent with precipitation/humidity proxies. However, the simulated
EASM–precipitation relationship is only stable on a centennial and longer
timescale and is unstable on a shorter timescale. The nonstationary
short-timescale EASM–precipitation relationship broadly exhibits a
multi-decadal periodicity, which may be attributed to the internal
variability of the climate system and has no significant correlation to
external forcings. Our results have implications for understanding the
discrepancy among various EASM proxies on a multi-decadal timescale and
highlight the need to rethink reconstructed decadal EASM variations based on
precipitation/humidity proxies.