Metal-free, nitrogen-doped carbon foam is utilized as a model non-precious electrocatalyst system to investigate the role of nitrogen in the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) in the absence of iron contamination. This graphene-like foam displays relatively high activity for the ORR in acid, despite being proven free from transition-metal impurities. The onset potential is 0.85 V RHE , the mass activity is 2.8 A/g at 0.6 V RHE , and the current density is −4.0 mA/cm 2 . The maximum electron transfer number is calculated to be 3.6, revealing that a 4-electron pathway is possible in nitrogen-doped carbon, even in the absence of transition-metal coordination sites. The excellent electrochemical activity is attributed to the large surface area (700 m 2 /g), improved conductivity after graphitization, and the relatively high proportion of tertiary (graphite-like) nitrogen. Non-platinum group metal (non-PGM) electrocatalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) are desired in order to reduce the cost and improve the durability of proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs). Transition metal-based electrocatalysts have long been suggested as alternative electrocatalysts. Starting in the 1970's, early attempts were made to utilize transition metal-containing macrocyclic complexes as biomimetric ORR electrocatalysts, taking inspiration from their usefulness in nature.1 However, soon it was discovered that heat-treatment of these macrocycles resulted in better activity and durability, 2 leading to debate over the precise chemical composition of the active site. Later still, it was realized that the macrocyclic complex was not necessary at all, but that seemingly arbitrary mixtures of Fe (or Co), nitrogen and carbon could lead to very active electrocatalysts.
3Since then, a vast amount of research output has been produced from a number of groups across the world. [4][5][6][7][8] In recent years, such electrocatalysts have become a mainstream research topic, with the DOE setting specific targets for a non-PGM cathode in a H 2 /air PEMFC; namely a volumetric activity of 300 A/cm 3 measured at 800 mV iR-free by 2017. 9 These targets have been all but met, 10 and non-PGM electrocatalysts are now commercially available.The issue of the nature of the active site has never gone away, and is still frequently debated.11 Complicating the issue is the fact that the ORR can proceed via either a 4-or 2-electron pathway to produce water or hydrogen peroxide (which can then further decompose to water), respectively. The 4-electron pathway is most desired in fuel cells, but the 2-electron pathway is significantly present in most non-precious electrocatalysts. The consensus in recent years has drifted toward the active site being comprised of pyridinic nitrogen atoms near a defect or edge, coordinated with a transition metal atom, with strong evidence of this provided by Mossbauer spectroscopy. 12 The clustering of nitrogen atoms in this manner has been observed in graphene in high resolution scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) measuremen...