Degrees of Intersectionality: Male Rap Artists in Sweden Negotiating Class, Race and Gender

Abstract

Abstract"Intersectionality" has become a highly influential concept in gender research over the last 25 years. Debates have focused on differences and power asymmetries between women, in terms of race but also addressing class, age, sexuality, ability and nation. However, intersectional paradigms have been used to a much lesser extent in gender studies on men. This article seeks to contribute to an emerging discussion about intersectionality and masculinity by analyzing rap lyrics in Swedish songs. The data consists of a broad sample of rap lyrics by male artists 1991-2011, which is analyzed through poststructuralist discourse analysis and queer phenomenology. The analysis shows how classed discourses can be described in terms of orientation and flow, how racialization is articulated in terms of place, and the role of normative notions of gender and sexuality in antiracist discourses. It is argued that this interconnectedness -class being related to race, which in turn is profoundly gendered -is neither well captured by the prevailing notion of "masculinities" in gender studies on men, nor by the "constitution" vs. "addition" dichotomy in intersectionality debates. Instead, it is suggested that degrees of intersectionality might be a more fruitful way of theorizing intersectionality in relation to men.

Härifrån till framtiden : Om gränslinjer, aktörskap och motstånd i tjejers vardagsliv

“…Bourdieus fenomenologiska influenser framhålls även av andra forskare (se t.ex. Broady 1988, Berggren 2013, Sohl 2014). Jag använder båda dessa begrepp, men orienteringsbegreppet kommer att användas i bredare bemärkelse än habitus.…”

Becoming horseboy(s) – human-horse relations and intersectionality in equiscapes

“…These are contexts that often are characterised by a hegemonic masculinity ideal, where approaching female-coded practices are heavily sanctioned (Messner, 1995;Willis, 1977). Also, Berggren (2013) illustrates that in male resistance against racialisation, stereotypical discourses on gender and sexuality are often drawn on. While combating racism, the norm that masculinity consists of heterosexuality, distancing from the feminine and none cowardness is reproduced and reinforced.…”

Hip hop feminism in Sweden: Intersectionality, feminist critique and female masculinity

“…Moreover, in Werner's ethnographic study of teenage girls' uses of music, the informants repeatedly voiced the opinion that boys and men were better suited to rapping than girls and women (Werner, 2009: 201). Furthermore, male artists' negotiations of masculinity have been studied (Berggren, 2012(Berggren, , 2013. But how do female rappers themselves negotiate gender in their lyrics?…”