Thermal stability of metastable silicon phases produced by nanoindentationSudden excursions of unusually large magnitude ͑Ͼ1 m͒, "giant pop-ins," have been observed in the force-displacement curve for high load indentation of crystalline germanium ͑Ge͒. A range of techniques including Raman microspectroscopy, focused ion-beam cross sectioning, and transmission electron microscopy, are applied to study this phenomenon. Amorphous material is observed in residual indents following the giant pop-in. The giant pop-in is shown to be a material removal event, triggered by the development of shallow lateral cracks adjacent to the indent. Enhanced depth recovery, or "elbowing," observed in the force-displacement curve following the giant pop-in is explained in terms of a compliant response of plates of material around the indent detached by lateral cracking. The possible causes of amorphization are discussed, and the implications in light of earlier indentation studies of Ge are considered.