Depth to compact subsoil effects on soil properties and barley–potato yields on a loamy soil in New Brunswick

Abstract

. Depth to compact subsoil effects on soil properties and barley Á potato yields on a loamy soil in New Brunswick. Can. J. Soil Sci. 95: 203Á218. An experiment was established to investigate the implications of thickness of soil over compact subsoil on plow layer soil thermal and water regimes and ultimately the yield of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) and barley (Hordeum vulgare L.). Three depths were considered, 24 cm (shallow), 36 cm (medium) and 60 cm (deep). Results on soil temperature impacts were inconclusive. The shallow treatment water content was most greatly affected by precipitation and had the greatest potential to become saturated then drying out more than the other treatments. The deep treatment did not improve soil temperature and water regimes enough to increase crop yield. The medium depth, which most closely approximated existing local solum development, proved superior to the shallow treatment in terms of crop yield and reduced soil moisture variation, while the deep treatment did not warrant the effort required to create under field conditions. Barley and potato yields from the medium depth were greatest with 20% (significant) and 8% (not significant) more yield, respectively, than from the shallow treatment. The eroded soil profiles common to the New Brunswick potato belt exacerbate soil erosion since an eroded soil has less volume to accept water from a rainfall event, making the soil more prone to erosion, especially if it is true that our weather is changing, with the amplitude of weather shifts becoming greater. Incorporation of subsoil materials into the plow layer of eroded soils due to soil loss may result in further reduction in crop yield. . Les effets sur la tempe´rature du sol ne sont pas concluants. Avec la couche peu e´paisse, la teneur en eau est particulie`rement touche´e par les pre´cipitations, et le sol court plus de risques de parvenir a`saturation puis de s'asse´cher que celui des deux autres traitements. La couche la plus e´paisse n'ame´liore pas assez la tempe´rature du sol ni le re´gime hydrique pour qu'on observe une hausse du rendement. La couche d'e´paisseur moyenne, qui correspond le plus au me´canisme local de de´veloppement du sol, s'ave`re supe´rieure a`la couche peu e´paisse au niveau du rendement et re´duit la variation de la teneur en eau du sol, les re´sultats obtenus avec la couche la plus e´paisse ne justifiant pas les efforts de´ploye´s pour ame´nager celle-ci au champ. C'est la couche d'e´paisseur moyenne qui assure le meilleur rendement de l'orge et de la pomme de terre, avec une hausse respective de 20 % (significative) et de 8 % (non significative) comparativement au rendement obtenu avec la couche peu e´paisse. Le profil e´rode´des sols commun a`la ceinture de la pomme de terre du Nouveau-Brunswick accentue l'e´rosion des terres dans cette province, car un sol e´rode´est moins volumineux et retient moins bien l'eau de pluie, le rendant plus sensible a`l'e´rosion, surtout si le changement climatique s'ave`re et accroıˆt l'amplitude des variations clima...

Soil properties and topographic features influence within‐field variation in potato tuber yield in New Brunswick, Canada

“…For example, whereas PC1 may reflect the response of tuber yield to spatial variation in soil texture and organic matter, the PC3 may reflect where there is a more pronounced effect of concave or convex landforms on tuber yield through soil water availability (drought or excess) or through soil depth (erosion or deposition). For example, there is evidence that tuber yield in New Brunswick is commonly limited by water availability (Bélanger et al, 2000) and by soil depth (Rees et al, 2015). This is consistent with the opposing direction of the vectors for slope curvature with silt and SOC in a biplot of PC1 vs. PC3 (Figure 3).…”

Soil compaction problems and subsoiling effects on potato crops: A review

“…However, the depth of compaction and water stress differs in deep-and shallow-rooted crops (Saini & Chow, 1982). For example, Rees et al (2015) evaluated the effect of compacted subsoil layers at three depths (10, 14 and 24 inches) on soil properties and yields of potato and barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) (i.e., shallow-and deep-rooted crops, respectively) in a loamy soil. For potato, they observed that yields averaged across 3 yr did not differ among the compacted layer depths, whereas barley yields significantly increased with the depth of the compaction layer.…”

Site-Specific Multilevel Modeling of Potato Response to Nitrogen Fertilization

“…As more limiting factors are relieved, nutrient use efficiency must increase. In the case of potato crops, irrigation scheduling (Haverkort and Struik, 2015), remedial measures against soil compaction (Stalham et al, 2005;Rees et al, 2015) and crop sequences could improve nutrient use efficiency.…”