In this study, a novel unit cell design is proposed, which eliminates the buckling tendency of the auxetic honeycomb. The novel unit cell design is a more balanced, diagonally reinforced doubly re-entrant auxetic honeycomb structure (x-reinforced auxetic honeycomb for short). We investigated and compared this novel unit cell design against a wide parameter range. Compression tests were carried out on specimens 3D-printed with a special, unique, flexible but tough resin mixture. The results showed that the additional, centrally pronounced reinforcements resulted in increased deformation stability; parameter-independent, non-buckling deformation behaviour is achieved; however, the novel structure is no longer auxetic. Mechanical properties, such as compression resistance and energy absorption capability, also increased significantly—an almost four times increase can be observed. In contrast to the deformation behaviour (which became predictable and constant), the mechanical properties can be precisely adjusted for the desired application. This novel structure was also investigated in a highly accurate, validated finite element environment, which showed that critical stress values are formed in well-supported regions, meaning that critical failure is unlikely. Our novel lattice unit cell design elevated the auxetic honeycomb to the realm of modern, high performance and widely applicable lattice structures.