Design for Resilient Human-System Interaction in Autonomy: The Case of a Shore Control Centre for Unmanned Ships

Abstract

Artificial intelligence is transforming how we interact with vehicles. We examine the case of Maritime Autonomous Surface Ships (MASS), which are emerging as a safer and more effective solution for maritime transportation. Despite the focus on autonomy, humans are predicted to have a central role in MASS operations from a Shore Control Centre (SCC). Here, operators will provide back-up control in the event of system failure. There are signification design challenges with such a system. The most critical is human-system interaction in autonomy (H-SIA). We consider humans as the source of resilience in the system for adapting to unexpected events and managing safety. We ask, can Human-Centred Design (HCD) be used to create resilient interactions between MASS and SCC? Work has been done in resilience engineering for complex systems but has not been extended to H-SIA in transportation. “Resilient interaction design” is relevant as we progress from design to operational phase. We adopted the ISO 9421-210 guideline to structure our HCD approach. The result is an SCC designed for 1 Autonomy Operator (AO). The contribution is a demonstration of how resilient interaction design may lead to safer and more effective H-SIA in transportation.

Remote Operation of Marine Robotic Systems and Next-Generation Multi-Purpose Control Rooms

“…In AURLab, simulators are used for various purposes, such as training our engineers and operators in the use of different vehicles, testing various mission scenarios, and introducing new algorithms in a safe and controlled environment without the risks and expenses associated with field deployments. Simulators also provide an environment to evaluate the behavior and operational performance of pilots under high cognitive load scenarios, e.g., piloting in challenging conditions, navigating through obstacles, or performing complex and multiple operations [48,49]. Furthermore, simulators are used in education to bring students closer to real underwater operations, to teach them how to operate different vehicles prior to field operations, and to motivate them to perform as many of their experiments as possible in a virtual environment, which is much more affordable and logistically less demanding.…”

milliAmpere: An Autonomous Ferry Prototype

“…The physical layout and instrumentation of the NTNU Shore Control Lab is based on resilience engineering and human-centered design methods [33]. Details on the lab's research aims and its integration with the rest of the NTNU autonomous ferry infrastructure are presented in [1].…”

Human-Centered Explainable Artificial Intelligence for Marine Autonomous Surface Vehicles

“…Work towards scaling MASS and ASVs into widespread use raises new challenges related to ensuring that AI system goals are aligned with the values of those who will be interacting with them. This is broadly the motivation behind the growing field of Explainable AI (XAI), characterized, as expressed by [13], by its mission to 'create AI systems whose learned models and decisions can be understood and appropriately trusted by end users' (p. 44). This mission is necessarily multi-disciplinary, meeting at the crossroads of fields as diverse as cognitive science, human-computer interaction, cybernetics, safety engineering, computer science, human factors, sociology, and others.…”